Children's Use of Novel Language
- If language were only copied and rewarded, you could produce nothing beyond what you had heard.
- Yet children constantly invent forms, and the clearest example is over-regularisation, like "goed" or "sheeps".
- No adult would say these words, so imitation cannot be where they come from.
- The child must be applying a grammar rule they worked out for themselves.
- Copying and rewards cannot produce brand-new errors a child has never heard.
- Novel language points to an inborn ability to form rules, which the learning theory leaves out.
Over-regularisation
- A child learns that you add "-ed" to make the past tense and "-s" to make a plural.
- They then over-apply that rule to words that break it, giving "goed" instead of "went" and "sheeps" instead of "sheep".
- The mistake is actually a sign of intelligence, because it shows the child gripping a rule rather than copying a phrase.
- A four-year-old comes in from the garden and says "I holded the snail and it goed in my hand".
- No adult ever said "holded" or "goed" to them.
- The child built those words by applying the past-tense rule, which imitation cannot explain.
Other Problems for the Theory
- Children pick up complex grammar remarkably fast, on messy and limited input, which slow trial-and-error learning struggles to match.
- Parents mostly react to what a child means, not to grammar, so correct sentences are rarely reinforced yet still develop.
- Chomsky called this the poverty of the stimulus, arguing the input is too thin to teach grammar and so some of it must be inborn.
- Do not swing too far and dismiss the learning theory outright.
- It still explains vocabulary and accent well; it is grammar it handles poorly.
A Balanced Conclusion
- Weigh the criticism against the support: Goldstein et al. show reinforcement really does shape early sounds.
- So learning explains part of language, while novel forms point to an inborn contribution.
- The strongest answer concludes that nurture and an inborn capacity work together, rather than choosing one.
- Why is novel language a problem for the learning theory?
- What is over-regularisation, and give one example?
- What does the poverty of the stimulus argument claim?
- What does the learning theory still explain well?