Skip to content

Course home

Revision guides·6.3.3 Argument against learning theory
Sign up

6.3.3 Argument against learning theory

Children's Use of Novel Language

  1. If language were only copied and rewarded, you could produce nothing beyond what you had heard.
  2. Yet children constantly invent forms, and the clearest example is over-regularisation, like "goed" or "sheeps".
  3. No adult would say these words, so imitation cannot be where they come from.
  4. The child must be applying a grammar rule they worked out for themselves.
Key Idea
  • Copying and rewards cannot produce brand-new errors a child has never heard.
  • Novel language points to an inborn ability to form rules, which the learning theory leaves out.

Over-regularisation

  1. A child learns that you add "-ed" to make the past tense and "-s" to make a plural.
  2. They then over-apply that rule to words that break it, giving "goed" instead of "went" and "sheeps" instead of "sheep".
  3. The mistake is actually a sign of intelligence, because it shows the child gripping a rule rather than copying a phrase.
Example
  • A four-year-old comes in from the garden and says "I holded the snail and it goed in my hand".
  • No adult ever said "holded" or "goed" to them.
  • The child built those words by applying the past-tense rule, which imitation cannot explain.

Other Problems for the Theory

  1. Children pick up complex grammar remarkably fast, on messy and limited input, which slow trial-and-error learning struggles to match.
  2. Parents mostly react to what a child means, not to grammar, so correct sentences are rarely reinforced yet still develop.
  3. Chomsky called this the poverty of the stimulus, arguing the input is too thin to teach grammar and so some of it must be inborn.
Common Mistake
  • Do not swing too far and dismiss the learning theory outright.
  • It still explains vocabulary and accent well; it is grammar it handles poorly.

A Balanced Conclusion

  1. Weigh the criticism against the support: Goldstein et al. show reinforcement really does shape early sounds.
  2. So learning explains part of language, while novel forms point to an inborn contribution.
  3. The strongest answer concludes that nurture and an inborn capacity work together, rather than choosing one.
Self review
  • Why is novel language a problem for the learning theory?
  • What is over-regularisation, and give one example?
  • What does the poverty of the stimulus argument claim?
  • What does the learning theory still explain well?
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 6.3.3 Argument against learning theory by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

Lesson

Recap your knowledge with an interactive lesson

8 minute activity

Start lesson

Learning theory suggests that language develops through imitation and reinforcement. If this were the whole explanation, children should only produce words and sentences they had previously heard and been rewarded for using.

Children regularly produce novel forms that no adult has said to them. This suggests that they are not only copying language, but also working out and applying grammatical rules. A key example is over-regularisation, where a child applies a normal grammar rule to an irregular word.

Questions

Put it into practice with exam-style questions

8 exam-style questions

Practice questions

Question 1

4 marks

Adults around four-year-old Nia usually speak in short, incomplete sentences. When Nia speaks, they respond to what she means but do not correct her grammar. Over time, Nia begins to use long sentences containing several clauses, although the adults have not used those sentence patterns around her.

Explain how this evidence can be used to assess the claim that learning theory fully explains children's language development.

Flashcards

Remember key concepts with flashcards

20 flashcards

Practice flashcards

Why would copying and rewards limit children's language?

6.3.3 Argument against learning theory Revision Guide

  1. IGCSE
  2. /Psychology
  3. /6.3.3 Argument against learning theory

Revision notes for CIE IGCSE Psychology 6.3.3 Argument against learning theory: explanations and worked examples.

More revision guides