Applying Chomsky's Explanation
- Application questions hand you a scenario and ask you to explain it.
- Your job is to pick the biological feature that best fits the behaviour described.
- The three features to choose from are the LAD, universal grammar and the critical period.
- Match the clue in the scenario to the feature that explains it.
- Then say how that feature accounts for the behaviour.
Reading the Clues
- Fast, untaught grammar
- If a child uses grammar rules nobody taught them, that points to the language acquisition device building the rules itself.
- The same building blocks in every language
- If the scenario stresses features shared across languages, that points to universal grammar, the structure Chomsky said all languages share.
- Trouble learning a first language late
- If someone struggles to master a first language as an adult, that points to the critical period having closed.
- A two-year-old says "we goed to Tesco", even though nobody around her says "goed".
- That invented rule is the LAD at work, not imitation, so the clue points straight to it.
A Worked Scenario
- A child grows up with almost no language around them and is only reached at 13; despite intensive teaching, they still struggle to pick up grammar and rarely form full sentences.
- Spot the clue: a first language is being learned late, well past early childhood, and it will not come easily.
- Name the feature: the critical period, the early window when the LAD works best, has largely closed.
- Explain it: because the child is past the critical period, the LAD can no longer pick up grammar easily, so progress stays limited despite the teaching.
- Do not describe the whole theory, and use only the feature the scenario calls for.
- Do refer back to the exact details you are given, because a general answer scores far less.
Answering an Application Question
- Identify the clue, name the matching feature, then explain how it accounts for the behaviour.
- The mark you drop is not tying your answer to the scenario, so quote the specific detail that gave the feature away.
- Which feature explains a toddler using grammar nobody taught them?
- Which feature explains an adult struggling to learn a first language?
- What clue in a scenario would point you to universal grammar?
- Why must you refer back to the scenario details in your answer?