Skip to content

Course home

Revision guides·6.2.6 Argument against Chomsky's biological explanation
Sign up

6.2.6 Argument against Chomsky's biological explanation

Limits of the Biological Explanation

  1. Critics argue that biology alone cannot explain how language develops.
  2. Culture and social contact clearly shape the language a child ends up with.
  3. That challenges a purely innate account built only on the LAD.
Key Idea
  • Without social contact, language does not develop normally.
  • That shows the environment matters, not just biology.

The Role of the Environment

  1. Children need to hear language used around them to learn it well.
  2. Without rich input, vocabulary and grammar stay limited, whatever the child is born with.
  3. This suggests real input, not just an LAD, is needed for language to develop fully.
Example
  • The case of Genie, a girl discovered after years of extreme isolation with almost no language around her, is often cited here.
  • Despite careful teaching afterwards, she never developed full grammar, which suggests biology on its own was not enough.

The Critical Period and Input

  1. Chomsky's own critical period shows that timing matters for language.
  2. But that timing only works if the environment provides language during the window.
  3. So even the biological timetable depends on input arriving at the right time.
Note
  • Languages differ hugely, from English to Welsh to Mandarin.
  • A child can only learn the specific words and rules of their own culture by being exposed to them, which biology alone cannot supply.

Nature and Nurture

  1. Senghas supports an innate basis: signers who began earlier developed more complex grammar, pointing to a critical period.
  2. Cases of neglect show that input is also needed for language to develop fully.
  3. The fair conclusion is that both nature and nurture play a part.
Common Mistake
  • Do not reject the theory outright, because it explains a great deal.
  • Do point out that it underplays the environment, which is where the criticism bites.

Writing a Balanced Critique

  1. State that biology alone is not enough, then give the environmental evidence to back it up.
  2. The mark you drop is balance, so weigh the criticism against Senghas before concluding that both matter.
Self review
  • What is the main criticism of Chomsky's biological theory?
  • How do cases of neglect challenge the theory?
  • Why is language input important, even if a critical period exists?
  • What is the balanced conclusion about nature and nurture?
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 6.2.6 Argument against Chomsky's biological explanation by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

Lesson

Recap your knowledge with an interactive lesson

8 minute activity

Start lesson

Chomsky argued that humans have an innate language acquisition device, or LAD, which helps children acquire language. The criticism is not that his account excludes linguistic input, but that a biological explanation may under-explain how social interaction, communicative context, and the nature of the language children hear contribute to development.

A child may be born with biological readiness for language, while the environment provides linguistic input that helps trigger and shape acquisition, including specific words, grammar, accent, and communication rules. Therefore, language development may be better explained by an interaction between biological predispositions, linguistic input, social interaction, and communicative context than by focusing on the LAD alone.

Questions

Put it into practice with exam-style questions

9 exam-style questions

Practice questions

Question 1

2 marks

Asha's birth parents speak Mandarin, but she is adopted at birth by a family who use Welsh at home. By the age of five, Asha speaks Welsh but has not learned Mandarin. Explain what Asha's language development suggests about a limitation of Chomsky's biological explanation.

Flashcards

Remember key concepts with flashcards

19 flashcards

Practice flashcards

What is the main criticism of Chomsky's biological explanation?

6.2.6 Argument against Chomsky's biological explanation Revision Guide

  1. IGCSE
  2. /Psychology
  3. /6.2.6 Argument against Chomsky's biological explanation

Revision notes for CIE IGCSE Psychology 6.2.6 Argument against Chomsky's biological explanation: explanations and worked examples.

More revision guides