Limits of the Biological Explanation
- Critics argue that biology alone cannot explain how language develops.
- Culture and social contact clearly shape the language a child ends up with.
- That challenges a purely innate account built only on the LAD.
- Without social contact, language does not develop normally.
- That shows the environment matters, not just biology.
The Role of the Environment
- Children need to hear language used around them to learn it well.
- Without rich input, vocabulary and grammar stay limited, whatever the child is born with.
- This suggests real input, not just an LAD, is needed for language to develop fully.
- The case of Genie, a girl discovered after years of extreme isolation with almost no language around her, is often cited here.
- Despite careful teaching afterwards, she never developed full grammar, which suggests biology on its own was not enough.
The Critical Period and Input
- Chomsky's own critical period shows that timing matters for language.
- But that timing only works if the environment provides language during the window.
- So even the biological timetable depends on input arriving at the right time.
- Languages differ hugely, from English to Welsh to Mandarin.
- A child can only learn the specific words and rules of their own culture by being exposed to them, which biology alone cannot supply.
Nature and Nurture
- Senghas supports an innate basis: signers who began earlier developed more complex grammar, pointing to a critical period.
- Cases of neglect show that input is also needed for language to develop fully.
- The fair conclusion is that both nature and nurture play a part.
- Do not reject the theory outright, because it explains a great deal.
- Do point out that it underplays the environment, which is where the criticism bites.
Writing a Balanced Critique
- State that biology alone is not enough, then give the environmental evidence to back it up.
- The mark you drop is balance, so weigh the criticism against Senghas before concluding that both matter.
- What is the main criticism of Chomsky's biological theory?
- How do cases of neglect challenge the theory?
- Why is language input important, even if a critical period exists?
- What is the balanced conclusion about nature and nurture?