Senghas and Nicaraguan Sign Language
- Deaf children in Nicaragua, brought together in new schools, spontaneously developed their own sign language.
- Senghas compared signers who had learned it from a very young age with those who started when older.
- The results let you argue that being ready to learn language early is built into the brain.
- Signers who learned from birth used more complex grammar than those who started later.
- That age effect points to a critical period, just as the biological explanation predicts.
What the Study Found
- Signers who had learned the language from birth used more verb inflections and more grammatical agreement.
- They also marked more of the "who did what to whom" information (the arguments of the verb) than later learners.
- So the earlier a child started, the richer and more complex their grammar became.
- A signer who learned from birth marks who did what to whom, using verb agreement so it is clear who pushed whom.
- A signer who only started as a teenager leaves more of that grammatical detail out, so their signing carries less information.
What It Shows
- The age at which someone starts learning language affects how complex their grammar can become.
- This is evidence for a critical period, an early window when the brain is primed for language.
- Because that readiness is set by the brain's development, it supports Chomsky's biological explanation.
- For this argument you are marked on the results and what they show, not the aim or procedure.
- Say early learners built more complex grammar, then tie it to the critical period.
Using It in the Exam
- State that earlier signers used more complex grammar than later ones.
- Link the age effect to the critical period.
- Conclude that this supports the biological explanation of language acquisition.
- What did Senghas find about the grammar of signers who learned from birth?
- Why does the age effect point to a critical period?
- Which part of Chomsky's theory does the study support?
- How does the study support a biological explanation of language?