Skip to content

Course home

Revision guides·6.2.5 Argument for Chomsky's biological explanation
Sign up

6.2.5 Argument for Chomsky's biological explanation

Senghas and Nicaraguan Sign Language

  1. Deaf children in Nicaragua, brought together in new schools, spontaneously developed their own sign language.
  2. Senghas compared signers who had learned it from a very young age with those who started when older.
  3. The results let you argue that being ready to learn language early is built into the brain.
Key Idea
  • Signers who learned from birth used more complex grammar than those who started later.
  • That age effect points to a critical period, just as the biological explanation predicts.

What the Study Found

  1. Signers who had learned the language from birth used more verb inflections and more grammatical agreement.
  2. They also marked more of the "who did what to whom" information (the arguments of the verb) than later learners.
  3. So the earlier a child started, the richer and more complex their grammar became.
Example
  • A signer who learned from birth marks who did what to whom, using verb agreement so it is clear who pushed whom.
  • A signer who only started as a teenager leaves more of that grammatical detail out, so their signing carries less information.

What It Shows

  1. The age at which someone starts learning language affects how complex their grammar can become.
  2. This is evidence for a critical period, an early window when the brain is primed for language.
  3. Because that readiness is set by the brain's development, it supports Chomsky's biological explanation.
Note
  • For this argument you are marked on the results and what they show, not the aim or procedure.
  • Say early learners built more complex grammar, then tie it to the critical period.

Using It in the Exam

  1. State that earlier signers used more complex grammar than later ones.
  2. Link the age effect to the critical period.
  3. Conclude that this supports the biological explanation of language acquisition.
Self review
  • What did Senghas find about the grammar of signers who learned from birth?
  • Why does the age effect point to a critical period?
  • Which part of Chomsky's theory does the study support?
  • How does the study support a biological explanation of language?
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 6.2.5 Argument for Chomsky's biological explanation by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

Lesson

Recap your knowledge with an interactive lesson

8 minute activity

Start lesson

Deaf children in Nicaragua were brought together in new schools and spontaneously developed their own sign language. This gave researchers a natural example of a language emerging within a community.

Senghas compared signers who were first exposed to Nicaraguan Sign Language before about age 10 with signers who were first exposed after about age 10. The key finding was that earlier-exposed learners developed richer and more complex grammar than later-exposed learners.

This age effect provides evidence for a critical period for language development.

Questions

Put it into practice with exam-style questions

10 exam-style questions

Practice questions

Question 1

4 marks

A researcher studies four groups who began regular exposure to their first fully developed language at different ages. Each group had used the language regularly for six years before being assessed.

Mean age when regular exposure began / yearsMean correct uses of verb inflections and grammatical agreement, out of 20
517.6
916.8
1510.4
189.8

Flashcards

Remember key concepts with flashcards

20 flashcards

Practice flashcards

What kind of grammar did signers who learned Nicaraguan Sign Language from birth use?

6.2.5 Argument for Chomsky's biological explanation Revision Guide

  1. IGCSE
  2. /Psychology
  3. /6.2.5 Argument for Chomsky's biological explanation

Revision notes for CIE IGCSE Psychology 6.2.5 Argument for Chomsky's biological explanation: explanations and worked examples.

More revision guides