Aphasia as Evidence for Localised Language
- The biological account says specific brain areas handle specific language jobs.
- Aphasia lets you test that claim, because you can see what happens when one area is damaged.
- When damage to a known area produces exactly the impairment you would predict, it supports the biological account.
- Where the damage sits predicts the type of aphasia.
- That predictable link is what shows language is localised in the brain.
Matching Damage to Deficit
- Damage to Broca's area in the frontal lobe produces Broca's aphasia, with halting, effortful speech.
- Damage to Wernicke's area in the temporal lobe produces Wernicke's aphasia, with fluent but confused speech and impaired understanding.
- Each pattern of impairment matches the normal job of the area that was damaged, which is the whole point of the evidence.
- A patient admitted to an NHS stroke ward has a stroke affecting the frontal lobe.
- Their speech becomes slow and effortful, the signature of Broca's aphasia.
- Because Broca's area normally builds speech, damaging it disrupts production, exactly as the biological account predicts.
What the Match Shows about Localised Language
- The tight fit between area and symptom shows language has specific locations in the brain.
- Production and comprehension rely on different areas, so they can be affected separately.
- Because this organisation is physical and consistent across patients, it supports a biological view of language.
- Aphasia is real-world evidence from real patients, not just theory.
- This makes it a strong point when you argue that the brain is built for language.
Turning Aphasia into an Evaluation Point
- Name the area, the matching impairment, then the conclusion that language is localised.
- The mark people miss is the conclusion, so always finish by saying what the case shows about the biological account.
- How does aphasia support the biological account of language?
- What does damage to Broca's area cause, and why?
- What does damage to Wernicke's area cause, and why?
- What does the damage-to-deficit match show about language localisation?