The Murdock Study
- The argument for the multi-store model comes from a study by Murdock.
- People heard lists of unconnected words and then recalled as many as they could, in any order.
- Where a word sat in the list changed how likely it was to be recalled.
Key Idea
- Words at the start and the end were recalled best, and words in the middle worst.
- The two raised ends point to two different stores doing the work.
What Murdock Found
- Words near the start of the list were recalled well, which is the primacy effect.
- Words near the end were also recalled well, which is the recency effect.
- Words in the middle were recalled worst of all.
- Plotted against position, this makes a U-shaped curve, high at both ends and low in the middle.
Why It Supports Two Separate Stores
- The early words were recalled well because there had been time to rehearse them into long-term memory.
- The last words were recalled well because they were still fresh in short-term memory.
- The middle words missed out on both, being neither well rehearsed nor still in mind.
- So the results fit short-term and long-term memory being separate stores, which is exactly what the model claims.
Note
- You only need this study's results and conclusion, and how they support the model.
- You are not asked for its aim, its procedure, or its strengths and weaknesses.
Using It in an Answer
- State the result: recall was best at the start and end of the list and worst in the middle, a U-shaped curve.
- Give the conclusion: the first words had been rehearsed into long-term memory and the last were still in short-term memory.
- Say what this shows, that short-term and long-term memory are separate stores; the result, conclusion and link are all that score, so writing Murdock's aim or procedure earns nothing.
Self review
- What pattern of recall did Murdock find across a list?
- Why were the words at the start of the list recalled well?
- Why were the words at the end of the list recalled well?
- How does this pattern support the multi-store model?