The Argument Against the Model
- Each theory in this topic has one argument for it and one against it, and you need both.
- The argument for the model is Murdock's study, which is covered separately.
- The single argument against it is that it cannot explain depth of processing.
Key Idea
- The model says the route into long-term memory is rehearsal, which really just means repetition.
- But how deeply you process something matters more than how often you repeat it, and the model cannot account for that.
Why Depth of Processing Is a Problem for the Model
- The model says information reaches long-term memory through rehearsal, meaning simple repetition.
- In practice, information you process deeply for its meaning is remembered better than information you just repeat by rote.
- The model has no way to explain this, because it counts only the amount of rehearsal, not the depth of it.
- That leaves it with an incomplete account of how long-term memories are actually formed.
Example
- Repeating a French word over and over is rehearsal, yet you may still forget it.
- Working out what the word means and using it in a sentence often fixes it far better, even with less repetition.
- The multi-store model cannot explain why the second approach wins, because it only tracks how much you rehearse.
Using the Argument in an Answer
- State the weakness as a plain point: the model cannot explain depth of processing.
- Explain why: it counts only rehearsal as repetition, yet processing for meaning fixes a memory better.
- If the item asks for one argument for and one against, pair this with Murdock's study as the 'for', since giving only one side caps a four-mark answer at three.
Self review
- What is the one argument against the multi-store model?
- According to the model, what moves information into long-term memory?
- Why is depth of processing a problem for the model?
- Which model explains depth of processing, unlike this one?