In every solid, conduction begins with lattice vibrations
Definition
Lattice vibration
The vibration of an atom or molecule about its fixed position in the regular arrangement of a solid, which grows stronger as the temperature rises.
- Heat one end of a solid and the particles there gain kinetic energy, so they vibrate more strongly about their fixed positions.
- Those particles are packed tightly against their neighbours, so a stronger vibration means they collide harder with the particles next to them.
- Each collision passes on some energy, so the neighbours begin to vibrate more strongly in turn, and the effect travels along the solid from the hot end towards the cool end.
- The energy moves but the particles do not, because each one stays around its own fixed position throughout, and that is what makes this conduction rather than convection.
- Passing energy neighbour by neighbour is a slow way of moving it, which is why non-metallic solids such as glass and brick conduct poorly even though this mechanism works perfectly well in them.
In metals, free electrons carry the energy far faster
Definition
Free (delocalised) electrons
Electrons in a metal that are not bound to any one atom and are free to move throughout the whole structure.
- A metal has the vibration mechanism as well, but it also has a sea of free electrons moving randomly through the whole lattice.
- At the hot end these electrons gain kinetic energy and move faster.
- Being free, they travel right across the metal rather than staying put, carrying that energy with them.
- When they reach the cooler part they collide with the atoms there and hand over energy, making those atoms vibrate more.
- This route is far quicker than the vibration route, because the electrons are light, fast, and cross the whole distance themselves instead of relaying energy from one neighbour to the next.
- Both mechanisms run at once in a metal, but the free-electron mechanism dominates, and that is the whole reason metals are the good thermal conductors.
- The same free electrons also carry electric current, which is why good electrical conductors are usually good thermal conductors as well.
Gases and most liquids conduct badly because the mechanisms barely work
- In a gas the particles are far apart, so a fast particle travels a long way before it meets another one and collisions are much less frequent.
- There is also no fixed arrangement in a gas, so there are no lattice vibrations to pass energy along, and energy can only be handed on collision by rare collision.
- In a liquid the particles are close together, so collisions are frequent, but they are not held in a rigid arrangement and so cannot pass on vibrations efficiently.
- Neither gases nor ordinary liquids have free electrons, so the fast mechanism is missing altogether, and the exceptions are the liquid metals such as mercury, which conduct well for exactly that reason.
- Gases are therefore the worst conductors of all, which is why trapping still air in a cavity wall, a duvet or a jumper is such an effective way of keeping energy where you want it.
- The air has to be kept still for this to work, because moving air carries energy by convection and undoes the benefit.
Example
- A metal teaspoon and a wooden stirrer are left standing in the same mug of tea.
- In the spoon, free electrons pick up energy from the hot end and shoot up the handle in seconds, colliding with atoms near the top.
- In the wood there are no free electrons, so energy can only crawl up by one particle nudging the next.
- The spoon becomes too hot to hold while the wooden stirrer stays cool at the top.
Common Mistake
- Do not write that the particles themselves travel along the rod, because in conduction they stay in their positions and only the energy moves.
- Do not say metals conduct well "because they are metals", because the mark is for the free electrons.
- Do not claim non-metals have no conduction mechanism at all, because lattice vibrations work in every solid and are simply slower.
- Do not explain a gas's poor conduction by saying its particles are slow, because gas particles are the fastest of all and it is the large spacing between them that matters.
Exam technique
- An explanation of conduction in a metal is worth two separate mechanisms, so write both: the lattice vibrations and, more importantly, the free electrons.
- Use the exact words vibrate, collide and delocalised, because vaguer wording such as "the heat moves along" earns nothing.
- When comparing a metal with a non-metal, make the comparison explicit by naming what the non-metal lacks.
- For a gas, base the answer on separation and collision frequency, and add that there is no fixed arrangement and no free electrons.
Self review
- Describe how thermal energy is conducted along a non-metallic solid.
- What are free electrons, and which materials have them?
- Explain why the electron mechanism is faster than the lattice vibration mechanism.
- Give two reasons why a gas is a very poor thermal conductor.
- Why must the air in loft insulation be kept still?