Choosing which risk to reduce
A council can afford to fund only one of two projects this year. An independent assessment provides the following information.
| Project | Estimated likelihood of the problem in the next 12 months | Consequences if the problem occurs | Estimated effect if the project is funded |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stabilise a retaining wall above a main road | 6% | The collapse could strike road users and close the road for 6–10 weeks. The diversion would add 45 minutes to journeys by residents and emergency services. | Likelihood reduced to 1% |
| Improve town-centre drainage | 65% | Flooding would close shops and the bus station for 3–5 days. Repair costs and business losses would total about £180,000. An early warning system would allow the area to be closed, so no direct risk to life is expected. | Likelihood reduced to 20% |
A councillor says:
“Since flooding is much more likely, funding the drainage project is the responsible choice.”
Discuss this view.
In your discussion, use details from the assessment and justify which project the council should fund.
Write approximately 400 words.
799 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.5 Section C: Writing, covering 2.5.2 Choice of discursive, narrative or descriptive task, 2.5.5 AO4 in Section C, and 2.5.6 AO5 in Section C. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.