The future of the market hall
A council must decide whether to demolish an unused market hall and build a community health centre on the site. Demolition cannot be reversed. Some residents have asked the council to postpone its decision for one year.
| Evidence | Information |
|---|---|
| Structural report | The hall can remain standing safely for one year if temporary work costing £180,000 is completed within eight weeks. |
| Restoration proposal | Full restoration is estimated to cost £3.8 million. A heritage group has £90,000 pledged and predicts that it could raise £600,000 within one year. |
| Health-centre proposal | Demolition and construction are estimated to cost £4.1 million. The new centre could provide 16,000 appointments each year; the current rented clinic can provide 9,000. |
| Funding position | A fund has offered £3 million towards the health centre if the council confirms the project within six months. A later application could be made, but no future funding is guaranteed. |
| Alternative site | Building the health centre elsewhere would cost an additional £1.2 million and delay its opening by 18 months, but the market hall could remain. |
| Public consultation | Of 1,200 respondents, 54% supported restoring the hall, 38% supported replacing it with the health centre and 8% expressed no preference. |
“Because demolition cannot be reversed, the council should delay its decision for one year.” Discuss.
In your discussion, use and interpret the evidence in the table, consider the consequences of both acting and waiting, and justify what the council should do.
Write approximately 400 words.
799 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.5 Section C: Writing, covering 2.5.2 Choice of discursive, narrative or descriptive task, 2.5.5 AO4 in Section C, and 2.5.6 AO5 in Section C. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.