The responsibility to notice
Read these two accounts.
Account 1
Mara is coordinating a public performance in a community hall. Before the audience enters, a volunteer tells her that a marked emergency exit has been sticking. Mara opens it once and it moves, so she returns to the entrance. Soon afterwards, two guests separately report that storage boxes are narrowing the route to the same exit. Mara has the storeroom key and could ask her deputy to check while she continues welcoming people, or delay the start. She does neither because she does not want to inconvenience the audience. The performance ends without an emergency.
Account 2
Eli is travelling on a bus when he notices that the passenger across the aisle looks pale and is sitting with their head lowered. Eli asks whether the passenger needs help. The passenger looks up and replies that they are fine, just tired. At the next stop, Eli could speak privately to the driver, but decides not to because he is worried about embarrassing a stranger. He moves to another seat when one becomes vacant. Five minutes later, the passenger faints. Another passenger alerts the driver, the bus stops and the passenger quickly recovers after being helped.
“People are as responsible for what they choose not to notice as for what they knowingly do.” Discuss.
In your response, use details from both accounts to compare Mara’s and Eli’s responsibility and reach a justified judgement about which, if either, is more blameworthy.
Write approximately 400 words.
799 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.5.2 Choice of discursive, narrative or descriptive task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.