Responsibility for helping
“People should be expected to help solve a problem only if they helped to cause it.”
Situation 1: Priya ignores an agreed plan and leaves boxes for a community book sale outside when rain begins. She can move them under cover safely in ten minutes. Ben followed the plan and has finished his own task. He could help Priya, but would lose ten minutes of his break.
Situation 2: On her way to an important appointment, Nadiya sees an unknown cyclist fall on a quiet road after hitting loose stones. Nadiya did not cause the accident. She can telephone for help and remain with the cyclist until it arrives, but she would miss her appointment and have to pay for another journey. She cannot safely lift the cyclist herself.
Discuss the statement by applying it to both situations. Compare what it is reasonable to expect from Priya, Ben and Nadiya, and justify how responsibility for the problem, ability to help and personal cost should affect your judgement.
Write approximately 400 words.
799 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.5.2 Choice of discursive, narrative or descriptive task. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.