A promise that can be kept
Text One: The radio at the end of the table
An original account by a volunteer at a community repair session.
Our poster said, ‘Bring it in — we’ll mend it.’ The words were cheerful, confident and large enough to read from across the community centre. At the time, that seemed exactly right. We wanted people to rescue neglected possessions rather than assume that nothing could be done.
Late in the afternoon, a visitor arrived carrying an old mains-powered radio. She had made a special journey because of our poster. However, our agreed rule was that such items could be opened only by the designated electrical repairer, who was not attending that session. The coordinator explained that we could record the details and suggest another service, but we could not examine the radio ourselves.
I was tempted to remove the back and have a quick look. I had repaired small things at home and disliked disappointing somebody who had trusted our invitation. Yet confidence was not the same as having an agreed role. The visitor accepted the referral, but asked a fair question: if we could not even inspect her radio, why had we claimed that we would mend whatever people brought?
At the next table, a different visitor produced a wooden writing box. It did not match any of the examples on our poster, but its problem was a loose hinge that one volunteer was able and authorised to repair. A narrow list might have turned away a job we could complete successfully.
During our review, we decided that refusing the radio had not been the mistake. The mistake was allowing our publicity to sound like a guarantee. We drafted a clearer invitation naming the kinds of work usually available and asking people to contact us before travelling with anything else. We also kept a record of the radio request. A limit should not be hidden, but repeated requests might show us which skills to add in future.
Text Two: What should a repair session promise?
An original article by the organiser of community repair events.
A broad invitation can encourage people to seek help before discarding an object. It can also reveal needs that organisers had not predicted. However, there is a difference between welcoming an enquiry and promising a completed repair.
The following outcomes were recorded across four recent sessions:
| Type of enquiry | Number of enquiries | Repaired during the session | Advice or referral given |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fabric items | 18 | 15 | 3 |
| Non-electrical household items | 10 | 7 | 3 |
| Mains-powered electrical items | 14 | 0 | 14 |
| Items outside the published examples | 8 | 2 | 6 |
These records show what visitors want as well as what the current team can provide. They should not be used merely to produce an impressive repair total. Advice, an explanation of a limit or a suitable referral may still be useful outcomes, although they are not the same as carrying out the requested work.
The scope of a session should reflect the people attending, their agreed roles, the available equipment and the time allowed. Public information must therefore be current. Organisers can name the categories they expect to handle while offering an advance enquiry route for other objects. A short description before the event allows a coordinator to decide whether to offer an appointment, request more information or explain that the item should be taken elsewhere.
Expansion should be evidence-led. Repeated enquiries may justify recruiting suitable support or arranging a limited trial of an additional category. They do not justify asking an unprepared volunteer to improvise. A trial can use booked appointments so that the team can review demand, outcomes and the time each case requires before making a larger promise.
Review all enquiries, including those that could not be accepted. Otherwise, a session may appear highly successful simply because difficult requests have disappeared from its records. A trustworthy service learns from what it cannot yet do as well as from what it repairs.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a proposal to the committee organising the next community repair session about whether the session should accept a wider range of objects and how the service should be presented and managed.
Your proposal should reach a justified recommendation.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.