Text One: More people, fewer repairs
An original account by a student who helped to organise a fictional school repair workshop.
Our lunchtime repair workshop began with a simple promise: bring us a torn pencil case, a loose button or another small fabric item, and we would try to help. Five students already knew some basic repairs, while the rest of us welcomed visitors, labelled items and watched demonstrations. We expected a quiet first session. Instead, a queue formed before we had finished arranging the thread and spare fabric.
At first, we treated the queue as proof that the workshop was succeeding. We entered a tick whenever anyone stopped at the table, including friends who came to watch and pupils returning to ask about an item. Our four-week summary looked impressive:
| Week | People recorded at the table | Items accepted for repair | Items ready by the following Wednesday |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 18 | 12 | 7 |
| 2 | 29 | 16 | 8 |
| 3 | 34 | 17 | 6 |
| 4 | 15 | 13 | 11 |
The third week had been promoted in every form room, so several pupils arrived together to watch a zip-repair demonstration. The five experienced volunteers spent much of that session explaining the display or searching for labels. In the fourth week, we asked pupils to leave their names on a booking sheet before lunchtime. Fewer people visited, but the table was calmer and more accepted items were ready by the next week.
Even these figures leave things out. An item listed as ready had not necessarily been collected. A few repairs had to be attempted again, and we declined some items because they needed equipment or expertise we did not have. The jobs were not equally difficult, either. Sewing on a button and rebuilding a damaged bag strap both counted as one repair.
There were benefits which our table did not capture. One pupil said that having a favourite pencil case repaired mattered more than receiving a replacement. Some visitors stayed to learn a stitch, and two later offered to volunteer. However, we often completed the work behind the table rather than teaching the owner how to do it. We had not decided whether our main purpose was to provide a service, reduce waste or help pupils learn practical skills.
Our feedback appeared strongly positive: 18 of the 21 returned slips rated the workshop useful. Only later did we remember that slips were usually placed beside completed items. Pupils whose items were refused, delayed or never collected were much less likely to receive one.
The practical strain also grew. Donated materials began to run out, the same five students completed most repairs, and a teacher regularly stayed for forty minutes after the workshop to supervise unfinished work. None of that appeared in our attendance total. I still believe the trial achieved something worthwhile, but a longer queue may have shown that we were attracting attention faster than we could provide a reliable service.
Text Two: Decide what continuation would mean
An original review by a community volunteer invited to advise the fictional school.
A popular launch can justify further investigation, but it does not by itself justify repeating a trial unchanged. Before continuing the repair workshop, the school should decide which outcomes matter. A service intended to complete repairs needs evidence about accepted, completed and collected items. A project intended to teach skills must record whether participants practise or demonstrate those skills. Claims about reducing waste require more than a count of visitors.
The existing figures should be interpreted cautiously. The attendance record includes spectators and repeat visits, while an item described as ready may remain uncollected. Changes between weeks also complicate comparison. Publicity increased attention in the third week, whereas advance booking altered access and working conditions in the fourth. The fourth week’s results may suggest that planning helped, but four unequal sessions cannot establish that booking alone caused the improvement.
A second phase could collect more useful evidence without becoming complicated. Record unique users as well as visits, and distinguish items accepted, completed, collected and declined. Note broad reasons for delay or refusal. Offer feedback to people at each stage, not only to those receiving successful repairs. A later check could ask whether a repair lasted or whether a participant used a skill again.
Evidence should include practical demands. Donated materials and voluntary effort are not unlimited simply because no invoice is produced. Record the materials used, the supervision required and whether work is shared among volunteers. If a small trained group continues to carry nearly all the responsibility, the workshop may be difficult to sustain even when users value it.
Continuation need not mean choosing between an unrestricted weekly service and complete closure. The school could narrow the kinds of item accepted, combine booked spaces with some opportunities for unplanned visits, or run teaching sessions separately from repair sessions. Clear information about what the workshop can attempt would reduce disappointment. Training additional volunteers could also make the project less dependent on its original organisers.
Any next phase should have a review date and agreed criteria. Leaders can then ask whether repairs are being completed and collected, whether pupils have fair access, whether skills are being shared and whether the time and materials required are manageable. The strongest recommendation will not be the most enthusiastic or the most cautious one. It will explain which benefits are worth preserving, which weaknesses need changing and what future evidence would justify continuing again.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a formal report to the school leadership team recommending whether and how the repair workshop should continue next term.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.