A garden with more than one purpose
Text One: The afternoon I cleared too much
An original account by a student helping in a school courtyard garden.
When I joined the courtyard gardening group, an open afternoon was only a week away. The entrance looked smart, but one corner contained dry leaves, old branches and several plants I could not name. I decided that the most useful thing I could do was make the whole garden look equally tidy.
I pulled up the unfamiliar plants, raked the leaves from beneath the hedge and carried the branches to the waste area. An hour later, there was a straight edge and plenty of bare soil. I took a photograph because the difference seemed impressive.
At lunchtime, the teacher who led the group asked where the purple flowers had gone. Students had been recording the insects which visited them. The leaves and branches had also been left in the quietest part of the garden to provide shelter. My work had been energetic, but it had removed several features before I understood why they were there.
The mistake was not entirely mine. There was no plan on display, so deliberate choices could easily be mistaken for neglect. We returned some of the leaves and branches to a strip behind the hedge. We also made small signs explaining the purpose of different areas.
Now, before changing anything, we spend time looking. We notice where pupils walk, which parts are sunny and what is already visiting the garden. We keep the route to the bench clear, but we do not expect every border to look the same. I have also begun making a weekly record of what we see. I used to think that gardening meant changing a place immediately. Sometimes it begins with deciding what should remain.
Text Two: Design before you dig
An original article by a school gardener about creating spaces for people and wildlife.
A wildlife garden does not need to look abandoned. However, it should not be judged only by straight edges and bare soil. Clearing every dry stem or fallen leaf may remove useful features, while allowing plants to cover paths can make the space difficult for people to enjoy. Both problems can be avoided through planning.
Begin by observing the site more than once. Sunlight, damp areas and wildlife activity may vary, and the routes used by visitors also need to be noticed. This information can help a group divide the space according to purpose.
A maintained path can guide feet away from quieter areas, while a seat can allow visitors to watch without disturbing them. Taller growth, fallen leaves or a stack of branches may be kept in selected places rather than spread across the whole garden. A map or a few clear signs can show that these features are intentional.
Make changes gradually and keep simple records of what happens afterwards. Photographs, dated notes and counts of visitors to particular plants can help a group judge whether its choices are working. If everything is altered at once, it is harder to understand which change produced a result.
There should also be different ways to take part. Some students may maintain paths or work with plants; others may draw maps, design signs or record observations. Welcoming people and supporting wildlife are not opposing aims. A thoughtful garden can do both.
Draw on ideas from both texts in your response.
Imagine you are addressing students who are considering joining the school gardening group. Write the speech you would give about creating a courtyard garden which works for both people and wildlife.
To help you plan, you could organise your speech in three stages:
Make your speech suitable for its audience and purpose.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.