Who deserves recognition?
Text One: The nominations on the table
An original account by a pupil helping to plan a fictional school celebration.
When I joined the celebration committee, the nominations had already been divided into piles. Highest examination result was easy to check. So was fastest runner. Beside these neat piles lay a thinner collection labelled contribution. Several forms said only that a pupil was helpful or worked hard.
One committee member suggested removing that category because it was too difficult to judge. Instead, we asked nominators to provide an example and describe its effect. The new details changed our discussion. We learned that Arun had arrived early each week to arrange music stands for the orchestra and had shared rehearsal information with absent members. None of these actions looked remarkable alone, but together they had enabled other pupils to participate.
The forms also revealed a problem with individual awards. One nomination praised the chair of the environmental team for organising a collection of unwanted stationery. However, other pupils had designed the notices, sorted the items and delivered them to classrooms. Naming only the chair would have turned shared work into one person's achievement.
Then we considered how recognition should be given. Jay had won a public-speaking competition and wanted to receive his certificate on stage. Amina, who had made considerable progress in reading aloud, preferred a letter sent home. She was proud of her improvement but did not want the personal reasons for it announced to the school. Eleni asked us not to mention the difficulties she had overcome at all. We realised that public praise is not automatically welcome simply because it is positive.
We redesigned the process. Pupils, teachers and support staff could all nominate someone, but each nomination had to identify an action and explain why it mattered. We kept separate categories for achievement, progress, contribution and teamwork so that unlike accomplishments were not forced into one competition. Groups could be recognised collectively, and recipients could choose between a public announcement, a written message and a private conversation.
At the celebration, the orchestra thanked Arun as part of its presentation. Every member of the environmental team was named together, while Amina received her letter privately. The event did not give everyone a prize, and it did not pretend that every contribution was identical. Instead, it made the reasons for recognition clearer and allowed success to take more than one form.
Text Two: Recognition without a single scoreboard
An original article by a teacher writing about achievement in schools.
Decide what recognition is for
Recognition can express gratitude, encourage worthwhile behaviour and show what a school values. However, an award can also narrow attention. If only results which are easily counted receive praise, pupils may conclude that improvement, cooperation and quiet service do not matter. If every helpful act earns a certificate, contribution may begin to look like a transaction rather than a responsibility.
Use clear but varied criteria
Fairness does not require every achievement to be judged by the same measure. Academic attainment, personal progress, creative work, teamwork and service involve different kinds of success. Separate criteria allow each to be considered seriously. Those criteria should be published so that pupils understand why recognition is given.
Nominations should include evidence. Rather than describing someone as dedicated, a nominator could identify what the pupil did, how consistently it was done and who benefited. Pupils and different groups of staff may notice different contributions, so the opportunity to nominate should not belong to only one group.
Choose an appropriate form
A stage, a noticeboard and a loud round of applause suit some achievements and some recipients. Others may be better acknowledged through a letter, a message to a family or a quiet expression of thanks. Schools should avoid revealing personal information merely to make an award sound more impressive. Wherever possible, the recipient should be consulted.
Team achievements require particular care. Praising only the most visible member can hide the planning, practical work and reliability of others. Collective recognition may give a more truthful account of how the result was achieved.
Review the pattern
Even clear systems can overlook people. Schools should review who is being nominated, what kinds of work are repeatedly rewarded and whether some criteria are difficult to use. This is not a reason to guarantee everyone an award. It is a way of checking whether the process notices the full range of contributions it claims to value.
Recognition should remain meaningful. The aim is neither a single ladder with one pupil at the top nor an endless supply of certificates. It is to notice significant achievement accurately, explain why it matters and acknowledge it in a way that respects the people involved.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a speech to be delivered at a meeting of pupils and staff in which you propose a fair way for your school to recognise pupils' achievements and contributions.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the pupils and staff you are addressing.
Planning support
Before writing, you may wish to:
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.