Whose wall is it?
Text One: The face in the painting
An original account by a resident responding to a proposed community mural.
The first drawing showed a huge face above the bus stop. The artist called it a portrait of our neighbourhood. I recognised the railway arches and the orange roofs behind the figure, but I did not recognise the person who was supposed to stand for us.
At the meeting, I said so. Someone replied that a painting could not contain everybody. That was true, although it did not explain why the same few people had decided what everybody would see each morning. Another resident wanted the wall left plain. I had assumed we were arguing about which picture to choose; she reminded me that choosing no picture was also a view.
The artist listened and returned with a different proposal. Instead of presenting a finished design, she brought smaller sketches and asked what places or details residents noticed. A mechanic suggested the blue shutters which opened before dawn. A child drew the peculiar shape of the hill beyond the roofs.
We did not agree on everything. I disliked the colour chosen for the background, and the resident who wanted a plain wall still preferred it. But the revised design no longer asked one invented face to carry the whole neighbourhood.
I support trying it on temporary panels, with permission from the people responsible for the site. I want to know how long it will stay and who will look after it. Being invited to comment should include a chance to ask what happens after the photograph of the opening day.
Text Two: Beyond the opening photograph
An original article by an artist who organises community mural projects.
A public painting changes a place for people who did not buy a ticket to see it. That makes consultation part of the work, not an obstacle to be removed before the brushes come out. An invitation to approve a completed design offers much less choice than a conversation before the design is settled.
Listening does not mean promising that every suggestion will appear. A painting needs a coherent idea, and some proposals will conflict. Explain how decisions are made, what limits the site imposes and which parts of the plan can still change. Include people who use the area at different times, not only those able to attend a single evening meeting.
Temporary panels can provide one way to test a proposal, where the site permits them. They still require permission, a suitable arrangement for installation and an agreed end date. The project should identify who will respond if the work is damaged and what will happen when the display ends. Temporary must not become a polite word for abandoned.
Opinions may remain divided. Record that honestly instead of describing the whole neighbourhood as enthusiastic because the opening attracted a cheerful crowd. Ask whether people understood the choices and had a fair opportunity to contribute, as well as whether they like the result.
An artist's skill matters, but so does a promise kept after the photographs. A community project earns its name through the way it works with people and fulfils its responsibilities, not simply through the number of local landmarks painted on a wall.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a letter to the editor of your local newspaper recommending how a proposed community mural should be planned and reviewed.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.