A welcome with clear boundaries
Text One: The table nearest the door
An original account by a customer at a fictional neighbourhood café.
I chose the café because it was quiet and near my evening class. On my third visit, a dog lay beneath the next table, with its lead stretched across the narrow space beside my chair. Its owner told me it was friendly before I had asked anything.
I was not worried that the dog intended to bite. I simply did not want to step over it or explain why sitting beside an unfamiliar animal made me uncomfortable. The reassurance answered a question the owner had imagined, rather than the difficulty I was actually having.
The server moved my cup to another table when I asked. She was kind, but there was little room, and I felt that my request had become the most noticeable thing I had done all evening. A sign outside had said dogs welcome. I had not known whether that meant every table, every time.
A week later, I returned with a friend who often walks there with her dog. We talked about what a clearer arrangement might look like. She wanted somewhere she could stop without going home first. I wanted to choose a seat without negotiating an animal's place beside it.
We did not settle the café's policy over two cups of tea. But it was useful to discover that neither of us wanted the other banished from the neighbourhood. We wanted to understand the welcome before arriving and to know whom to ask if the arrangement was not working.
Text Two: Welcoming does not mean assuming
An original account by the owner of another fictional neighbourhood café.
Customers sometimes describe a café policy as though one cheerful sign can settle every practical question. I have learned that a welcome is also an arrangement: where people can sit, how movement is kept clear and what staff should do when different needs meet.
Some dog owners value being able to stop while out walking. Some other customers prefer space away from animals. Neither group consists of people with identical preferences. A statement that a particular dog is friendly does not explain whether its lead is obstructing a route or whether the person at the next table wants contact.
Any policy needs to fit the premises and the requirements which apply to them. I check those matters rather than copying a neighbouring business's sign. If separate areas or times are considered, they must be workable and explained honestly; a tiny corner cannot be advertised as a solution to every concern.
Staff need clear arrangements and a way to deal with questions without inviting customers to argue across the room. Owners bringing animals should understand their responsibilities, and other customers should be able to ask about seating without being required to justify a personal preference in public.
We review what happens in practice, including requests from people who stopped visiting. A policy is not proved successful merely because the people who like it say so. The aim is an understandable choice and a considerate response when ordinary situations reveal a gap in the plan.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a letter to the editor of a local newspaper discussing how cafés could make their arrangements about dogs clearer and more considerate.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.