A gift with room to choose
Text One: The red mug
An original account by a teenager choosing a birthday present for a cousin.
I chose the mug because I liked it. It was red, solid and wide enough to hold both my hands. By the time I wrapped it, I had almost forgotten that my cousin drank from a narrow cup and disliked red.
She thanked me and found a place for it on her shelf. I waited for more enthusiasm, then felt unfairly disappointed when she changed the subject. The present had begun as something for her and somehow become an examination of whether she would appreciate my choice.
A month later, she gave me a small packet containing a replacement for the unusual pen I had complained about losing. It was not a surprise in the way the mug had been. It showed that she had remembered a conversation which I had forgotten having.
I asked how she knew which kind to buy. She said she had checked with my sister rather than trying to guess. I used to think that asking a question spoiled a present. Now I wondered whether preserving the surprise had mattered more to me than choosing something useful to its owner.
I still like giving unexpected things, and my cousin still keeps the mug. Next time, though, I will listen before I shop and let her decide what to do with the result. A gift should not come with an invisible request to prove that the giver knows best.
Text Two: Attention before wrapping paper
An original article by a writer discussing everyday gift-giving.
A present can express affection, thanks or a wish to share something enjoyable. The difficulty begins when the giver's imagined response becomes a condition attached to it. The recipient may value the relationship without wanting the object to occupy a permanent place in their home.
Think about the person rather than the performance of giving. Notice what they use, what they have mentioned and what they would prefer not to receive. Where appropriate, a discreet question can prevent a mistaken assumption. A surprise is one possible pleasure, not the only measure of thoughtfulness.
There is also no single suitable form. A practical item may show close attention; time spent helping with an agreed task may be more welcome than another possession. Check that an offer of help is wanted rather than presenting the recipient with a plan they must now accommodate. Avoid commitments which you cannot realistically keep.
Choose within your circumstances. A costly object does not automatically express greater care, and a competition over presents can make an occasion uncomfortable. An explanation of why you chose something may communicate more than elaborate wrapping, provided it does not require the recipient to deliver a particular reaction.
Receiving involves courtesy, but gratitude need not mean pretending that every choice was perfect. Giving involves a corresponding freedom: allow the other person to decide how the gift fits their life. Attention matters both before the wrapping is opened and after the thank-you has been said.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write an article for a youth magazine with the title “A gift with room to choose”. Advise readers about thoughtful giving without creating pressure for the recipient.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.