Making lunchtime our own
Text One: A lunch without a screen
An original account by a student trying a phone-free lunch table.
We began with one table and a cardboard sign. Nobody surrendered a phone. We simply agreed to keep them in our bags while we ate. On the first day, three people sat down, followed by a fourth who had misunderstood the sign and stayed anyway.
The conversation was awkward. A screen can provide somewhere to look when you do not yet know what to say. Without it, I became aware of how often I used checking a message to end a sentence I had not really finished. By Thursday, we had learned enough about one another to continue a conversation from the day before.
I would not claim that every silent person around a phone is unhappy. One friend uses lunch to speak to her sister, who attends another school. Another reads a downloaded chapter because the dining hall is already more company than he wants. Neither needs a lecture about the superiority of our table.
What helped was having something small to do together. Someone brought a quick card game, and we agreed that people could watch without playing. We did not photograph the group to prove how sociable we had become.
After two weeks, the sign was less important than the habit. New people still sometimes needed an invitation. A phone-free table had made conversation easier for some of us, but it had not removed the work of making space for someone who did not already know where to sit.
Text Two: A choice for the whole lunch break
An original contribution by a student-support coordinator.
Students have suggested a phone-free lunchtime across the school. Before choosing a rule, we should decide which problem we want to solve. A device may interrupt a conversation. It may also help a student arrange collection, contact family or enjoy a quiet break after a demanding morning.
A useful starting point would be a voluntary area with clear expectations and activities which do not require expensive equipment. Students should help choose and run it. If the only invitation is a notice about what people must stop doing, we have not offered much reason to join.
We should also think about space. A quiet reading corner and a lively games table serve different needs. A student who wants silence should not have to defend it as a temporary problem which conversation will cure. Equally, someone who wants company may need a personal invitation rather than a public announcement.
There would be practical limits. Staff need to know where help can be found, and students with an agreed reason to use a device should not have to explain private arrangements to a table of strangers. We can make the expectations clear without turning every exception into a public argument.
After a short trial, ask who attended, who felt welcome and who stayed away. Counting phones alone would tell us little about the experience. The aim should be a better lunch break, not a photograph in which no screen happens to be visible.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write an article for your school magazine with the title “Making lunchtime our own”. Explain how the school could offer a more enjoyable and inclusive lunch break.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.