Instructions that actually work
Text One: The flap we folded too soon
An original account by a student testing instructions for a paper model.
Our class made a paper model from a sheet of instructions I had written. I expected to spend the lesson watching other people succeed. Instead, I watched them fold a flap which they needed to leave flat until the next stage.
The instruction said fold the small flap inward. There were two small flaps. In my own model, one was already held out of the way, so I had not thought to identify which one I meant. The photograph did not help: my hand covered the part everyone needed to see.
I walked around correcting people until the teacher asked me to stop. If I explained every uncertain step aloud, she said, we would be testing my presence rather than my page. I found it surprisingly hard to watch someone hesitate without supplying the missing sentence.
We recorded the places where readers stopped. I numbered the stages, used the same name for each part and took another photograph without my hand in it. I also moved the list of materials to the beginning. A reader should not reach stage four before discovering that a tool is needed.
The second group still asked one question, about whether the printed side should face upwards. I added that detail too. The finished instructions were longer than my first version, but less difficult to use. What had seemed obvious to me was precisely what I had needed someone else to test.
Text Two: Writing for a person who cannot ask you
An original article by a writer of practical instruction sheets.
Instructions succeed when another person can use them, not when the author feels that the process has been described. Familiarity is a difficulty here: the writer may no longer notice the small choices which a beginner must make deliberately.
Start with the intended result and the things needed to reach it. Put essential preparation before the first action. Divide the process into stages in a useful order, using consistent names for parts. A command such as attach it can become confusing if several objects might be meant. Identify the object and any orientation which matters.
Pictures can show a relationship more quickly than a sentence, but they must reveal the relevant detail. A beautiful photograph from the wrong angle may explain less than a plain diagram. Keep the image close to the stage it supports, and do not expect a picture to repair an instruction which refers to the wrong part.
Test the sheet with someone who does not already know the process. Unless an immediate concern requires intervention, let the reader show where the wording fails instead of quietly rescuing it through extra explanation. Record hesitation as well as completed mistakes. Ask afterwards what the person expected a phrase to mean.
Revision is not simply adding more words. Remove repetition, clarify the troublesome choice and test again. Some processes need a caution or an instruction to seek appropriate help, but a general warning cannot substitute for a usable sequence. The final sheet should allow the author to leave the room without taking the essential information away.
Use ideas from both texts to answer this question.
Write a contribution to a student project website with the title “Instructions that actually work”. Advise students preparing instructions for someone unfamiliar with their project.
You should include:
Think carefully about your purpose and the audience for whom you are writing.
212 exam-style questions on Edexcel B IGCSE English Language 2.4.2 Directed writing task based on source texts. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.