Skip to content

Course home

Sign up

3.1.4 Effects on wider society

  1. The effects of significant mental health problems reach past the individual into services, the economy and families.
  2. Society has to organise and pay for care, absorb the work that is lost, and lean on unpaid carers to cover the gaps.
Key Idea
  • The cost of mental health problems lands on health services, employers, the welfare system and families rather than on one person alone.
  • Care moved out of the large hospitals and into local teams, so support now arrives at a person's home instead of on a ward.
  • How well that works depends on funding, because thin community support shows up as long waits and repeat admissions.

Care in the community

Definition

Care in the community

Care in the community is an approach that supports people with mental health problems through local services and in their own homes, rather than in long-stay hospitals.

  1. The 1959 Mental Health Act started the shift by allowing voluntary treatment, and in 1961 the Minister of Health announced that the large mental hospitals would close.
  2. The NHS and Community Care Act 1990 made local councils responsible for assessing what a person needs and arranging the care.
  3. Psychiatric bed numbers in England fell from roughly 150,000 in the mid-1950s to under 20,000 today, so almost all care now happens outside hospital.
  4. In place of a long stay, a person is supported by a community mental health team of psychiatrists, nurses, psychologists and social workers.
  5. A community psychiatric nurse visits at home, checks how medication is going, and can pick up a relapse early.
  6. A crisis resolution and home treatment team can step in at short notice and support a person through a crisis at home.
  7. Supported housing, day services and the GP cover the everyday parts, and the Care Programme Approach names one care co-ordinator to hold it all together.
Example
  • A man in his thirties diagnosed with schizophrenia lives in his own flat and sees a community nurse each fortnight.
  • He keeps his tenancy, his part-time job and his football team while his treatment continues.

Evaluating care in the community

  1. Society gains when a person stays near family, keeps a tenancy, and avoids the loss of everyday skills that a long institutional stay causes.
  2. Community support also costs less per person than a hospital bed, so the same budget reaches more people.
  3. The model needs enough trained staff, and shortages show up as long waits between a referral and a first appointment.
  4. Where support thins out, people are readmitted again and again, a pattern often called the revolving door.
  5. Some people lose contact with services altogether, and insecure housing or homelessness follows.
  6. Police and ambulance crews then end up as the first responders to a mental health crisis.
  7. Well-funded community care helps a great many people recover and live independently, so the model is judged on how it is resourced.
Note
  • The hospital closures and the new community services did not arrive together, so some people were discharged before local support was in place.
  • Comparing the two systems on cost alone leaves out what a long stay took from a person, such as everyday skills and contact with family.

The economic cost

  1. Someone who is unwell may need time off work, so the economy loses the output they would have produced.
  2. Employers carry the sickness absence, the cost of recruiting a replacement, and reduced output from staff who are at work but struggling.
  3. The NHS pays for appointments, medication, talking therapy and hospital beds.
  4. The welfare system pays benefits when a person cannot work, and councils pay for social care and supported housing.
  5. The Centre for Mental Health has put the cost to England at well over £100 billion a year.
    1. Treat a figure like that as an estimate, because it adds spending, lost output and a value placed on reduced quality of life.
  6. Early treatment lowers the total, since a problem caught in a ten-minute GP appointment costs far less than a crisis admission.
Example
  • A supermarket supervisor is off work for six months with depression, so her employer pays sick pay and covers her shifts with overtime.
  • At the same time the NHS funds her therapy and medication, so one person's illness shows up in three separate budgets.

Mental health problems and crime

  1. The large majority of people with a mental health problem never commit an offence.
  2. People with a severe mental illness are considerably more likely to experience crime than the general population is.
  3. Where a small association does turn up, it usually tracks other factors such as untreated illness, substance use, poverty or having no support in place.
  4. News coverage that pairs a diagnosis with a violent crime makes the link look far larger than the evidence supports, and that coverage is itself a source of stigma.

The load on families and carers

  1. Relatives provide most day to day support once care moves into the community, and they are usually unpaid.
  2. Some cut their hours or leave work to do it, which costs the household its income and the economy its output.
  3. Young carers may miss school or fall behind, so the effects pass into the next generation.
  4. Carers are more likely to become unwell themselves, which is why councils offer a carer's assessment and respite breaks.
Note
  • Carers belong in this topic as an effect on society, because the unpaid hours they give are work the state would otherwise have to buy.
  • A carer's own health is counted separately, so one household can be carrying two sets of needs at once.

Turning this into marks

  1. When two effects on society are asked for, make them genuinely separate rather than one effect rephrased.
  2. Name the specific service or law, such as the community mental health team or the NHS and Community Care Act 1990, because a general reference to support in the community does not secure the knowledge mark.
  3. The mark most often lost is describing an effect on the individual when the question asked about society.
Self review
  • What is care in the community, and what did it replace?
  • Name three people or services that make up support in the community.
  • Give one advantage and one problem of care in the community for society.
  • Name three separate budgets that a single person's mental health problem can draw on.
  • Why should any claimed link between mental health problems and crime be stated with care?
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 3.1.4 Effects on wider society by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

Lesson

Recap your knowledge with an interactive lesson

10 minute activity

Start lesson

The effects of significant mental health problems extend beyond the individual. Health services, employers, the welfare system and families may all carry part of the cost.

Society must organise and fund care, cope with lost work and rely on unpaid carers. This means one person’s mental health problem can affect several services and budgets at the same time.

Flashcards

Remember key concepts with flashcards

22 flashcards

Practice flashcards

What does care in the community provide instead of long-stay hospital care?

3.1.4 Effects on wider society Revision Guide

  1. GCSE
  2. /Psychology
  3. /3.1.4 Effects on wider society

Revision notes for OCR GCSE Psychology 3.1.4 Effects on wider society: explanations and worked examples.

Revision guides