Diagnosing schizophrenia in the ICD
Schizophrenia
A serious mental health condition that affects how a person thinks, feels and perceives reality, involving symptoms such as hallucinations and delusions.
- Schizophrenia is a serious mental health condition that changes how a person thinks, feels and experiences the world around them.
- Its clinical characteristics are set out in the International Classification of Diseases, published by the World Health Organization, and the current version is ICD-11.
- ICD-11 requires at least two of its listed symptoms, present for at least one month, before schizophrenia is diagnosed.
- At least one of those two has to come from the positive group, so negative symptoms on their own are not enough for the diagnosis.
- A diagnosis needs at least two of the listed symptoms, present for at least a month, with at least one of them from the positive group.
- That is why an experience such as hearing a voice narrate your actions, or holding a belief that evidence cannot shift, sits at the centre of the diagnosis.
- Symptoms rise and fall over time, and with treatment and support many people manage the condition well or recover.
How the diagnosis is reached
- The symptoms must also not be explained by something else, such as a brain tumour, a drug, or the side effects of medication.
- A psychiatrist therefore takes a full history and rules out the other possible causes.
- ICD-11 dropped the older subtypes such as paranoid and catatonic, so there is now one diagnosis rated on which symptoms a person currently has.
- Hearing a voice once is not schizophrenia, because the symptoms have to last a month and other causes have to be excluded first.
- A drug, a physical illness or the side effects of medication can produce similar experiences, which is why the history comes before the diagnosis.
- Dropping the subtypes means a person is described by the symptoms they have now rather than by a fixed label.
Positive symptoms
Positive symptoms
Symptoms that add something to a person's experience which is not usually present, such as hallucinations or delusions.
- Hallucinations
- A hallucination is a sensory experience of something that is not there, and in schizophrenia it is most often auditory.
- A person may hear one or more voices commenting on what they are doing, and the voice sounds as real to them as any other sound in the room.
- Delusions
- A delusion is a belief held firmly even when there is clear evidence against it.
- Common forms are delusions of persecution, a belief that the person is being followed or plotted against, and delusions of grandeur, a belief that they have special powers or importance.
- Disorganised thinking
- Thoughts jump between loosely connected ideas, which shows up as speech that a listener cannot follow, and in severe cases as scrambled speech called word salad.
- Experiences of influence, passivity and control
- Thoughts, feelings or movements feel as though something outside the person is controlling them.
- ICD-11 includes thought insertion, where a thought feels planted from outside, and thought broadcasting, where a person believes others can hear their thoughts.
- Disorganised behaviour and psychomotor disturbance
- Behaviour becomes odd or aimless, such as wearing a winter coat in July or laughing with no trigger.
- Psychomotor signs include holding one unusual posture for a long time, or barely moving and speaking at all.
- A man hears a voice narrating his actions while he makes a cup of tea.
- He is also certain a television presenter is speaking to him personally, and being shown the schedule does not shift the belief.
Negative symptoms
Negative symptoms
Symptoms that involve a loss or reduction of normal functioning, such as reduced speech, low motivation or flattened emotion.
- Avolition
- Motivation and energy drop, so starting and finishing everyday tasks such as washing, cooking or getting to college becomes very hard.
- Blunted or flat affect
- The face, voice and gestures show much less feeling, so a person can sound flat while describing something upsetting.
- Alogia
- Speech becomes sparse, and answers shrink to a few words even when the question invites much more.
- Asociality
- A person spends far less time with friends and family and stops seeking company out, because the drive to socialise is itself reduced.
- Anhedonia
- Things that used to be enjoyable stop giving any pleasure, including food, music and a match they once never missed.
- Symptoms come and go over time, and with treatment and support many people manage the condition well or recover from it.
- Dangerousness is not one of the clinical characteristics, and people with schizophrenia are more likely to experience violence than to commit it.
- The two groups are easy to run together, and the difference between them is direction, since positive symptoms add something and negative symptoms take something away.
- Positive means added and negative means lost, so neither word is a judgement about how bad the symptom is.
- Schizophrenia involves hallucinations and delusions, and a split personality is a separate and much rarer condition.
Turning this into marks
- When two symptoms are asked for, make them genuinely separate rather than one symptom rephrased.
- Use the clinical term from the ICD, so avolition rather than laziness, because an everyday description does not secure the knowledge mark.
- Where a question asks how the diagnosis is made, give the threshold of two symptoms for one month with at least one of them positive.
- The mark most often lost is giving two positive symptoms when the question asked for one of each type.
- What is the difference between a positive and a negative symptom?
- Name three positive symptoms listed in ICD-11.
- What do avolition, alogia and anhedonia each mean?
- How many symptoms does ICD-11 require, and for how long?
- What is thought insertion?