Skip to content

Course home

Sign up

3.1.3 Effects of stigma and discrimination

Stigma and discrimination

Definition

Stigma

Stigma is the unfair negative judgement attached to a characteristic, such as having a mental health problem, which can leave a person feeling ashamed or being treated differently.

  1. Stigma is the set of negative attitudes, beliefs and stereotypes people hold about mental health problems.
  2. Discrimination is the unfair treatment that follows once those attitudes turn into behaviour.
  3. Both can reach a person before diagnosis and after diagnosis.
  4. The two feed each other, because unfair treatment confirms the stereotype and the stereotype licenses more unfair treatment.
Key Idea
  • The heaviest cost of stigma is delay, because a person who expects to be judged waits before asking for help.
  • A longer untreated period usually means a longer recovery and more time lost from school or work.
  • Discrimination then removes the things that support recovery, such as a job, an income and everyday company.
  • Recovery stays realistic throughout, and treatment and support return many people to work, study and family life.

Stigma before diagnosis

  1. Expecting to be judged stops a person seeking help, so a problem that could be treated early is left to grow.
  2. Many people turn the stereotype on themselves, which is called self-stigma, and feel ashamed or weak before anyone has assessed them.
  3. Self-stigma lowers self-esteem, and low self-esteem is itself a symptom that makes depression harder to shift.
  4. Some people conceal symptoms from family, friends and teachers, and so lose the support that would help them cope.
  5. Concealment also means the people around them read the changes as rudeness or laziness.
  6. Delay pushes diagnosis later, and a longer untreated period usually means a longer recovery and more time lost from school or work.
Example
  • A man who has felt low for months tells nobody, because he expects to be called weak for saying it out loud.
  • He books a GP appointment a year later, by which time his sleep, his work and his relationships have all suffered.

Stigma after diagnosis

  1. Once a diagnosis is known, people may respond to the label instead of the person, so it overshadows everything else about them.
  2. Public myths about mental illness shape how people respond to a diagnosis.
    1. People with a severe mental illness are more likely to experience violence than the general population is.
    2. Schizophrenia is a condition involving hallucinations and delusions, and it has nothing to do with having two personalities.
  3. Being seen through the label lowers confidence and expectations, so a person steps back from work, education and friendships.
  4. Self-stigma continues after diagnosis, and a person may decide for themselves that they will never work or study again.
  5. Stigma can spread to the family too, so parents and partners are asked what they did wrong.
  6. That withdrawal isolates the person further and makes the condition harder to manage.

Discrimination before diagnosis

Definition

Discrimination

Discrimination is treating someone unfairly because of a characteristic such as a mental health problem. It is stigma turned into action, for example refusing someone a job or leaving them out.

  1. Unfair treatment can begin long before any diagnosis, because other people react to the changes they have noticed.
  2. At school or at work a person who misses lessons or shifts is left out, teased, or written off as unreliable.
  3. Without a diagnosis there is no formal support and no reasonable adjustment in place, so the treatment goes unchallenged.
  4. There is no legal protection either, since the Equality Act works from a recognised long-term condition.
  5. Being treated this way makes a person even less willing to come forward, so the delay caused by stigma gets longer.
Example
  • A Year 11 pupil who has gone quiet and withdrawn is dropped from a group project because classmates assume she will not do her share.
  • Nobody has diagnosed anything, and she is already losing opportunities, marks and confidence.

Discrimination after diagnosis

  1. A known diagnosis can mean being turned down for a job, passed over for promotion, or managed out of a role.
  2. In healthcare, physical symptoms are sometimes put down to the mental health problem, which is called diagnostic overshadowing.
    1. Chest pain read as anxiety means a heart problem gets missed, and this is one reason people with a severe mental illness die younger on average.
  3. Losing work means losing income, and losing income puts secure housing at risk.
  4. Friends drift away and relationships come under strain, so a person loses the practical support that helps recovery.
  5. Under the Equality Act 2010 a long-term mental health condition counts as a disability, so this treatment can be unlawful and adjustments such as changed hours can be requested.
Note
  • The Equality Act gives a person a route to challenge unfair treatment, but it does not prevent the treatment happening in the first place.
  • Adjustments have to be asked for, so a person who has chosen not to tell an employer about a diagnosis cannot draw on them.

Reducing stigma and discrimination

  1. Attitudes shift most when people meet someone with lived experience, which is why Time to Change was built around social contact between the public and people with a diagnosis.
  2. Teaching about mental health in schools replaces the myths with the ICD characteristics, so a diagnosis carries accurate information.
  3. Media guidelines on how mental illness and suicide are reported cut the number of stories that link a diagnosis with violence.
  4. Employers who advertise adjustments make it safer to disclose a diagnosis and keep a job at the same time.
  5. Recovery is a realistic outcome, and with treatment and support many people diagnosed with a significant mental health problem go back to work, study and ordinary family life.
Note
  • Effects on society sit alongside the effects on a person, and they include lost work, extra demand on health services and the cost of illness left untreated.
  • None of these measures works quickly, because attitudes shift over years rather than with a single campaign.

Turning this into marks

  1. When two effects are asked for, make them genuinely separate rather than one effect rephrased.
  2. Say whether the effect is stigma or discrimination and whether it falls before or after diagnosis, because an answer that could apply to any of the four does not secure the knowledge mark.
  3. Ground each effect in one specific consequence, such as a lost job or a missed appointment.
  4. The mark most often lost is describing an effect on the person when the question asked for an effect on society.
Self review
  • What is the difference between stigma and discrimination?
  • What is self-stigma, and how does it affect someone before diagnosis?
  • Give one effect of stigma on a person after diagnosis.
  • Why is discrimination before diagnosis harder to challenge than discrimination after it?
  • What is diagnostic overshadowing?
PreviousNext

How was this guide?

Teach Genie

Review 3.1.3 Effects of stigma and discrimination by teaching Genie

Teach it back in your own words, spot gaps, and remember it better.

Start teaching
Genie and Baby Genie

Lesson

Recap your knowledge with an interactive lesson

9 minute activity

Start lesson

Stigma is the set of negative attitudes, beliefs and stereotypes attached to a characteristic such as having a mental health problem. Discrimination is the unfair treatment that follows when those attitudes become behaviour.

Both can affect a person before diagnosis and after diagnosis. They can also reinforce each other: unfair treatment appears to confirm the stereotype, while the stereotype is used to justify further unfair treatment.

The main difference is that stigma is an attitude or judgement, whereas discrimination is an action. Examples of discrimination include excluding someone or refusing them a job.

Flashcards

Remember key concepts with flashcards

21 flashcards

Practice flashcards

How does expecting judgement affect help-seeking before diagnosis?

3.1.3 Effects of stigma and discrimination Revision Guide

  1. GCSE
  2. /Psychology
  3. /3.1.3 Effects of stigma and discrimination

Revision notes for OCR GCSE Psychology 3.1.3 Effects of stigma and discrimination: explanations and worked examples.

Revision guides