This article covers 3.2.2 Language, thought and communication of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Signs That NVC Is Inborn
- Some non-verbal behaviour appears without anyone teaching it, which points to an innate origin.
- The strongest evidence comes from newborn babies and from people born blind.
- If these groups still produce the expressions, they cannot have copied them, so the behaviour is likely inherited.
Key Idea
- Innate behaviour appears without being learned.
- Newborns and people born blind could not have watched and copied expressions.
- This supports Darwin's evolutionary account that NVC is inherited.
Newborn Babies
- Newborns pull clear facial expressions in the first days of life, long before they could learn by imitation.
- A baby only hours old screws up its face in disgust at a sour or bitter taste.
- Because there has been no time to learn these faces, they suggest expressions are present from birth.
Example
- Offer a newborn a taste of something bitter and its nose wrinkles and mouth turns down in a disgust expression, even though it has never seen anyone else react to food.
People Born Blind
- People born blind smile when happy and frown when upset, just like sighted people.
- Eibl-Eibesfeldt studied children born both deaf and blind and found they still laughed, smiled and pulled sad faces normally.
- Because these children could never have seen the expressions to copy them, this strongly supports an innate basis for NVC.
Note
- This evidence is strongest for basic facial expressions, not for every kind of NVC.
- Gestures and personal space vary between cultures, so the learned side is covered in the next article.
How Far It Supports Darwin
- A strength is that newborn and blind evidence removes the chance of learning by imitation, which makes it convincing support for the innate claim.
- A further strength is that the same basic expressions turn up across many cultures, which fits an inherited, universal origin.
- A limitation is that studies of children born deaf and blind use small, unusual samples, so the findings may not generalise to everyone.
- A final limitation is that the evidence only covers basic expressions and cannot explain gestures or personal space, so overall it points to a nature-nurture picture rather than pure instinct.
Self review
- What evidence suggests NVC is innate?
- Why is behaviour in people born blind useful evidence?
- Which theory does this support?
- What does this evidence not rule out?