This article covers 3.2.2 Language, thought and communication of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
NVC as Learned Behaviour
- Some non-verbal behaviour differs from one culture to the next, which shows it must be learned.
- If a signal were purely inherited, it would look the same everywhere, so variation points to nurture.
- Yuki's study of how people read faces is the key piece of evidence here.
Key Idea
- If NVC differs across cultures, it is at least partly learned.
- Learned behaviour is picked up from the people around you as you grow up.
- This challenges a purely innate account of NVC.
Cultural Variation in NVC
- Gestures carry different meanings in different cultures, so their meaning cannot be inborn.
- Personal space norms also vary, with people in some cultures standing much closer than in others.
- Because children absorb these norms from the people around them, the behaviour must be learned.
Example
- A thumbs-up means well done to a British teenager but counts as a serious insult in parts of the Middle East, so the same gesture is read in opposite ways.
- A V-sign with the palm facing inwards is a rude gesture in Britain yet harmless in many other countries.
Yuki's Emoticon Study
- Yuki compared how Japanese and American participants judged emotion in faces and in emoticons.
- Japanese participants relied more on the eyes, so they judged a smiley mainly by its eyes.
- American participants relied more on the mouth, so they read the same feeling from the shape of the mouth.
- Because the two groups read the same faces differently, Yuki concluded that culture shapes how we interpret NVC.
Common Mistake
- Do not conclude that all NVC is learned, because basic expressions such as happiness appear to be innate.
- Aim instead for a balanced nature-nurture conclusion.
Weighing Learned Against Innate
- The learned evidence is strong for gestures, personal space and how faces are read, which the innate account struggles to explain.
- However, Yuki's study compared only Japanese and American participants, so the sample may not represent every culture.
- The innate account still holds for basic expressions seen in newborns and people born blind, so neither side wins outright.
- The balanced conclusion is that basic expressions are inherited while gestures, space and interpretation are learned, so NVC reflects both nature and nurture.
Self review
- What does cultural variation suggest about NVC?
- What did Yuki find about reading faces?
- Give an example of a gesture that varies by culture.
- What is the balanced conclusion on NVC?