This article covers 3.2.2 Language, thought and communication of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Darwin: Our Expressions Are Built In
- Darwin argued that non-verbal communication is inherited rather than learned.
- He claimed it evolved because it helped our ancestors survive, which is why it is described as adaptive.
- If NVC really is inherited, then the same basic expressions should appear in every human culture.
Key Idea
- NVC evolved because it helped survival, so it is passed down in our genes.
- Facial expressions signal emotions and intentions in an instant.
- If the theory is right, expressions such as fear and anger should be recognised worldwide.
How Signalling Emotion Aids Survival
- A fearful face makes the eyes widen, which lets you take in more of a threat and warns others nearby that danger is close.
- An angry face bares the teeth and lowers the brow, which can scare off a rival before any fight breaks out.
- Because these signals gave an edge in staying alive and reproducing, they were passed on to the next generation.
Example
- Cross a quiet car park at night and hear footsteps behind you: your face snaps into a wide-eyed fear expression before you have even decided to feel afraid, and anyone nearby reads the danger at once.
- That same fear face looks much the same whether the person is from Britain, Brazil or Japan.
Evaluating the Innate Claim
- A strength is that basic expressions such as happiness and fear are recognised across very different cultures, which fits an inherited origin.
- Further support comes from newborn babies and from people born blind, whose expressions are examined closely in the next article.
- A weakness is that some non-verbal behaviour, such as gestures, clearly differs from culture to culture, which suggests learning also shapes NVC.
- The safest conclusion is a nature-nurture position: the theory explains inherited expressions well but cannot account for the parts of NVC that are learned.
Common Mistake
- Do not claim that all NVC is innate, because gestures and cultural display rules plainly vary.
- Outline the theory first, then weigh the evidence on both sides before you reach a conclusion.
Outlining and Evaluating the Theory
- State that NVC is evolved, inherited and adaptive.
- Explain how signalling emotion aids survival, backed by an example.
- Evaluate whether NVC is truly innate, using evidence for and against.
Self review
- What does Darwin's theory say about NVC?
- How does NVC aid survival?
- What evidence supports the innate claim?
- What challenges the innate claim?