This article covers 3.2.1 Social influence of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Bystander Behaviour: Why a Crowd Can Mean Less Help
Definition
Pro-social behaviour
Any action intended to help or benefit another person, such as comforting, sharing or coming to someone's aid.
- Prosocial behaviour is any act that helps someone else, and bystander behaviour is how you act when you see a person who needs help.
- Whether you step in is shaped by the situation around you and by your own characteristics.
- The strange finding is that having more people around often makes help less likely, not more.
Key Idea
- The bystander effect is the finding that you help less when others are present than when you are alone.
- Social factors are about the situation; dispositional factors are about the person.
Social Factors
Definition
Diffusion of responsibility
The tendency to feel less personal duty to act when others are present, because each person assumes someone else will take responsibility.
- Presence of others
- The more people who are present, the less likely any single person helps, because responsibility is shared out through diffusion of responsibility.
- Each person assumes someone else will act, so in the end no one does.
- Cost of helping
- If stepping in is risky, difficult or embarrassing, the cost feels high and helping becomes less likely.
- When helping is quick and safe, the cost is low and people are far more willing to act.
Example
- Picture a packed platform at Birmingham New Street in rush hour, where a man suddenly stumbles and slumps against a pillar.
- Surrounded by hundreds of commuters, each person assumes someone else will help, and the cost of missing their train adds to the reasons to walk on.
- Alone on a quiet platform, the same person would almost certainly stop, because the responsibility rests only on them.
Dispositional Factors
- Similarity to the victim
- You help more when the person in need seems similar to you, for example the same age or wearing the same team's shirt, because you identify with them.
- Expertise
- If you have relevant skills, such as first aid training, you feel more able to help and so you are more likely to step in.
Common Mistake
- Do not lump every factor together: the presence of others and the cost of helping are social, while similarity and expertise are dispositional.
- Do not treat the bystander effect as being about the victim; it is about how many other people are there.
Explaining a Factor in an Answer
- Name the factor and say plainly whether it makes helping more or less likely.
- Explain the reason behind it, for example that diffusion of responsibility spreads the sense of duty thin.
- The mark students drop is the mechanism, so never just state the effect without saying why it happens.
Self review
- What is the bystander effect?
- What is diffusion of responsibility?
- How does the cost of helping affect whether someone intervenes?
- How does similarity to the victim change the chance of helping?