This article covers 3.2.1 Social influence of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Obedience from the Inside
- Dispositional factors explain obedience through the person's own personality, not the situation around them.
- Adorno argued that some people have an authoritarian personality that makes them readier to obey.
- He thought these traits grow out of a strict, harsh upbringing in childhood.
Key Idea
- The dispositional view locates the cause of obedience inside the person.
- Certain fairly stable personality traits predispose someone to obey authority.
The Authoritarian Personality
Definition
Authoritarian personality
The authoritarian personality is a set of traits, including strong respect for and submission to authority plus hostility towards those seen as lower status, thought to make a person more likely to obey.
- Submission to authority
- Someone high on this trait respects and obeys those above them almost without question.
- Hostility downwards
- They tend to be rigid in their thinking and hostile or dismissive towards people they see as lower in status.
- Roots in upbringing
- Adorno linked it to a strict, punishing childhood, where the child could not challenge their parents and later directed that resentment at weaker targets.
Example
- A worker who always defers to a strict manager, never questions an instruction, and looks down on junior staff would likely score highly on Adorno's F-scale, the questionnaire he used to measure the trait.
- Because the personality is fairly stable, this person would tend to obey across many different situations, not just one.
Dispositional Versus Situational
- The dispositional view puts the cause in the person's personality, so it predicts some people will obey almost anywhere.
- The situational view puts the cause in the setting, so it predicts almost anyone will obey given the right pressures.
- A full explanation of obedience probably needs both, because personality and situation interact.
Common Mistake
- Do not claim personality is the only cause: Milgram showed situational factors alone moved obedience up and down sharply.
- A weakness of the dispositional account is that it struggles to explain whole populations obeying at once, which points back to the situation.
Describe, Then Compare
- Name the traits precisely. Adorno's authoritarian personality submits to those above, turns hostile towards those seen as below, and thinks in rigid black-and-white terms, all traced back to a strict childhood.
- Link each trait to obeying instead of just listing them. Someone who defers to authority without question and wants a clear hierarchy will follow an order others would refuse.
- Name the F-scale as the way Adorno measured the trait. It is an easy detail to earn, and most answers leave it out.
- For a compare question, state the actual point of difference rather than describing each view separately. Personality predicts the same person obeying almost anywhere, while the situational view predicts almost anyone obeying under the right pressure.
Self review
- What is a dispositional explanation of obedience?
- Name two traits of the authoritarian personality.
- How did Adorno measure it?
- How does the dispositional view differ from the situational view?