This article covers 3.2.1 Social influence of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Piliavin's Subway Study: Helping as a Cost-Benefit Decision
- Piliavin, Rodin and Piliavin staged a collapse on a New York subway train to see when strangers help.
- The same victim appeared either ill or drunk, which changed how much help he got.
- The results show that people weigh up costs and rewards before deciding to step in.
Key Idea
- An ill victim carrying a cane was helped quickly and almost every time.
- A drunk victim was helped less and more slowly, because helping him felt more costly.
Aim
- The aim was to find out what makes people help a stranger who collapses in a public place.
- In particular, they tested whether the type of victim, ill or drunk, changed how much help was given.
- They also checked whether having more passengers around reduced helping, as lab studies of the bystander effect suggested.
Method
- It was a field experiment run on a New York subway train during a journey of about seven minutes with no stops, so the passengers had no idea they were being studied.
- A male confederate, a person secretly working for the researchers, collapsed to the floor about a minute into the journey.
- In one condition he carried a walking cane and looked ill, and in another he smelled of alcohol and carried a bottle, so he looked drunk.
- Two observers recorded who helped, how quickly and the sex and race of the helpers, across roughly 100 trials.
Example
- In the cane condition the victim was usually helped within seconds, often by more than one passenger at once.
- In the drunk condition passengers often hesitated, glanced away, or waited to see what others would do.
Findings
Definition
Cost-reward model
The idea that seeing an emergency makes you feel unpleasant arousal, and you decide whether to help by weighing the costs and rewards of helping against the costs of not helping.
- The ill victim was helped in almost every trial, and usually within seconds.
- The drunk victim was helped less often and after a longer delay, because helping him carried a higher cost such as disgust or the risk of aggression.
- Men did most of the helping, and people were slightly more likely to help a victim of the same race, especially in the drunk condition.
- Having more passengers present did not reduce helping, so the bystander effect was much weaker than in lab studies.
Note
- Piliavin concluded that people weigh costs and rewards, helping fast when the cost is low and the reward is clear.
- On a train you cannot walk away and you can see the victim clearly, which raises arousal and pushes people to act.
Evaluation
- Strength: real setting
- Real commuters who did not know they were being studied behaved naturally, giving the study high ecological validity and no demand characteristics.
- Weakness: narrow sample
- The passengers were New York subway riders on one route in the early 1970s, so the results may not generalise to rural areas, other cultures or the present day.
- Weakness: ethics
- Passengers could not give consent and could not easily leave a moving train, and some may have been alarmed by seeing a man collapse, with no debrief afterwards.
- Weakness: little control
- The researchers could not control how many people were in each carriage or whether any knew first aid, so these extraneous variables may have affected who helped.
Self review
- What was Piliavin's aim?
- Who was helped more, the ill or the drunk victim, and why?
- Which model of helping do the findings support?
- Give one reason the sample limits how far the findings generalise.