This article covers 3.2.1 Social influence of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Does a Group Change What You Say?
Definition
Conformity
Conformity is changing your behaviour or opinions to match a group, usually because of real or imagined pressure from that group.
- Solomon Asch wanted to see whether you would give an answer you knew was wrong, just because other members of the group did.
- He used a task so easy that on your own you would get it right almost every time.
- That way, any wrong answer in the group had to come from social pressure, not from genuine confusion.
Key Idea
- Asch showed that many people go along with a clearly wrong majority out loud.
- This was public compliance, because participants doubted the group privately but still agreed in public.
Aim and Method
- Aim
- To find out whether people would conform to a majority that gave an answer which was plainly wrong.
- Method
- 123 male American college students each judged which of three comparison lines matched a standard line, a task with one obvious correct answer.
- Each real participant sat with several confederates who gave the same wrong answer on set trials, and Asch recorded whether the lone participant went along with them.
Note
- The participant always answered second to last, so they heard almost the whole group before speaking.
- A control group answering alone got it right nearly every time, so any errors in the group came from the majority.
Findings and Variations
- On average, participants conformed on about a third (32%) of the critical trials.
- About three quarters conformed at least once, while about a quarter never conformed at all.
- Group size
- Conformity rose as confederates increased to three, then levelled off, so a bigger majority added little.
- Unanimity
- One confederate who gave the right answer cut conformity sharply, because the majority was no longer united against the participant.
- Task difficulty
- Making the lines closer in length raised conformity, because unsure participants relied on the group for the answer.
- Link to the specification: group size and task difficulty are two of the social factors AQA lists for conformity, and Asch's variations are the evidence for them, all showing majority influence at work.
Example
- Afterwards, most conformers said they had known the right answer but went along to avoid the group's disapproval, which points to normative social influence.
- Because their private view had not changed, this is compliance rather than internalisation.
Evaluation
- Strength: strong control
- The lab set-up held everything constant except the confederates' answers, so Asch could be confident the majority, and not some other factor, caused the conforming, and the study replicates reliably.
- Weakness: narrow sample
- The 123 participants were all male American students, so the findings may not extend to women, older adults or more collectivist cultures, which limits how far you can generalise them.
- Weakness: a child of its time
- Asch ran the study in 1950s America, an unusually conformist decade, and when Perrin and Spencer repeated it with UK students in 1980 they found far less conformity, so the result is not fixed across time.
- Weakness: artificial task
- Judging lines among strangers is trivial and unlike the real pressure of conforming among friends over money, risk or beliefs, so the study has low ecological validity.
Note
- Participants were deceived about the confederates, though the task itself caused only mild, brief discomfort rather than any real harm.
Writing About Asch
- Open with the set-up in one sentence. Asch had 123 male US students judge which of three comparison lines matched a standard while confederates called out the same wrong answer aloud.
- Give the actual numbers rather than a vague 'many people conformed'. Around 32% of critical responses went along with the majority, roughly three quarters conformed at least once, and about a quarter never did.
- If a variation is named, say what it did to conformity. One dissenting confederate cut it sharply, a majority larger than three added almost nothing, and closer comparison lines pushed it up.
- Only evaluate when the command word asks you to. The tight lab control is the strongest positive; the narrow 1950s all-male American sample is the criticism that examiners reward most.
Self review
- What task did Asch use, and who were his participants?
- Roughly what proportion of responses conformed?
- How did adding one dissenting confederate change conformity?
- Give one reason Asch's sample limits how far the findings generalise.