This article covers 3.2.1 Social influence of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
What Tips You Towards Conforming
- Several factors push how likely you are to conform up or down.
- These factors split into social factors that come from the situation and dispositional factors that come from you.
- Classic studies, mainly Asch's line-judgement work, give the evidence for each one.
Key Idea
- Social factors come from the situation around you; dispositional factors come from the kind of person you are.
- Each factor makes conforming either more or less likely, and you should be able to say which way and why.
Social Factors
- Group size
- As the majority grows to about three people, conformity climbs sharply, because a united group of several feels much harder to defy; adding people beyond that barely changes it.
- Anonymity
- When you can answer privately, conformity drops, because nobody can see your response, so the pressure to fit in falls away.
- Task difficulty
- The harder the task, the more you conform, because when you are unsure of the answer you look to the group to guide you.
Example
- In Asch's line-judgement task, a single confederate barely swayed the real participant, but a group of three pushed conformity up to around a third of responses, showing group size matters until the group is large enough to feel like a majority.
- When Asch made the comparison lines closer in length, so the task got harder, conformity rose, because unsure participants leaned on the group for the answer.
Dispositional Factors
- Personality
- Some people are naturally more independent, so they hold their own line and conform less, while others are keener to please and conform more.
- Expertise
- If you know a lot about the task, you trust your own judgement, so the group sways you far less.
- There is evidence behind both factors: people who trust their own expertise conform less, shown by conformity dropping when a task is easier and people rely on their own judgement, and more independent personalities hold their own line against the group.
Common Mistake
- Do not mix social and dispositional factors: if the cause sits in the situation it is social, if it sits in the person it is dispositional.
- For every factor, name it, say which way it moves conformity, and back it with evidence.
Explaining a Factor
- Start by pinning the factor to its source. If it comes from the situation it is social; if it comes from the kind of person you are it is dispositional, and examiners test that label directly.
- State which way it moves conformity and be precise where you can. Group size lifts it up to about three people and then levels off, so a loose 'bigger groups mean more conformity' will not earn full credit.
- Then explain the mechanism, the step most students skip. A harder task makes you doubt yourself so you lean on the group; an expert trusts their own judgement so the group sways them less.
Self review
- Name two social factors that affect conformity.
- How does task difficulty affect conformity, and why?
- Name the two dispositional factors AQA lists for conformity.
- How does expertise affect conformity?