This article covers 3.1.3 Development of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Studies of Conservation and Egocentrism
Key Idea
- Piaget's own tasks suggested young children cannot conserve or take another view.
- Fairer replications, the studies AQA names, show they can do both earlier than he claimed.
Piaget's Conservation Study
- Piaget (1952) showed a child two identical rows of counters and the child agreed the rows had the same number.
- One row was then spread out so it looked longer, even though not a single counter was added or removed.
- Children under about seven said the longer-looking row now had more, so they failed to conserve.
- Children of about seven and over said the number was still the same, so Piaget concluded conservation appears in the concrete operational stage.
Example
- Picture lining up two rows of Smarties, then sliding one row apart so it stretches further across the table.
- A young child insists the longer row has more sweets, even though they just watched you move them, not add any.
McGarrigle and Donaldson: The Naughty Teddy Study
- Aim
- To test whether Piaget's deliberate rearranging of the counters made children fail for the wrong reason.
- Method
- Children saw two equal rows of counters, then a naughty teddy glove puppet messed up one row by accidentally spreading it out.
- Findings
- When the change looked accidental, about 60 percent of four to six year olds correctly said the number was still the same, far more than in Piaget's version.
- Conclusion
- Children can conserve earlier than Piaget claimed; his deliberate change seems to have made them think they were meant to give a different answer.
Example
- Picture a teacher who deliberately rubs out your answer and asks the same question again.
- You might well change it, assuming they want something different, which is exactly the trap Piaget's own task set for young children.
Piaget and Inhelder's Three-Mountains Task
- This task tested egocentrism, a young child's tendency to see a scene only from their own viewpoint.
- Piaget and Inhelder (1956) built a model of three mountains, each marked by a feature such as snow, a hut or a red cross.
- A child viewed the model from one side, then a doll was placed facing the mountains from another angle, and the child chose the photograph showing what the doll could see.
- Four-year-olds almost always chose their own view, while by about seven children began to choose the doll's view, which Piaget took as egocentrism easing as the child decentres.
Example
- The snowy mountain might sit on the child's left but on the doll's right, so the doll's photo should look flipped.
- A younger child ignores this and keeps picking the view from their own chair.
Hughes: The Policeman Doll Study
- Aim
- To test egocentrism with a task that made human sense to a young child.
- Method
- Children had to hide a boy doll from one and then two policeman dolls behind walls arranged in a cross shape.
- Findings
- About 90 percent of children aged three and a half to five hid the doll correctly, even from two policemen at once.
- Conclusion
- Young children are far less egocentric than the three-mountains task implied; the earlier failure came from a confusing, unfamiliar task.
Note
- Hiding from a policeman is something a child understands and cares about, unlike choosing a photo of a mountain.
- To hide the doll they must work out the policeman's line of sight, which means taking his viewpoint, not their own.
Evaluating These Studies
- Strength: the tasks were standardised and controlled, so they can be repeated and give reliable results.
- Weakness: Piaget's samples were small and drawn mainly from Swiss children, so the exact ages may not generalise to all children or cultures.
- The named replications show that task design, not a lack of ability, caused some of the failures, so do not treat Piaget's ages as exact cut-offs.
- Relate them to the theory: they challenge Piaget's ages while still supporting his broad idea that children's thinking becomes less bound by appearance as they get older.
Self review
- What did Piaget's conservation task show about children under seven?
- How did McGarrigle and Donaldson's naughty teddy study challenge that finding?
- What did the three-mountains task suggest about young children, and what does egocentrism mean?
- How did Hughes' policeman doll study challenge the three-mountains finding?