This article covers 3.1.3 Development of the AQA GCSE Psychology specification.
Dweck: Your Belief About Ability Shapes What You Do
Definition
Growth mindset
The belief that your intelligence and ability can grow through effort, good strategies and practice. Challenges and mistakes are then seen as chances to improve rather than as threats.
- Dweck found that what you believe about the nature of ability quietly steers how you behave when work gets hard.
- She described two mindsets: a fixed mindset and a growth mindset.
- Which one you hold shapes your motivation, the effort you put in and how you react the moment you fail.
Key Idea
- It is the belief about ability, not your actual ability, that drives the behaviour.
- Two pupils of equal talent can respond to the same setback in opposite ways because they believe different things.
The Two Mindsets
Definition
Fixed mindset
The belief that your intelligence and ability are fixed traits that cannot really be changed. Effort then feels pointless and failure feels like proof that you simply lack talent.
- With a fixed mindset you treat ability as a set trait, so a poor result feels like a verdict on how clever you are.
- That makes you avoid hard tasks, because failing would seem to prove you lack the talent you were counting on.
- With a growth mindset you treat ability as something that grows with effort and better strategies, so a poor result is just information.
- That makes you seek out challenge, because a hard task is exactly where your ability can stretch.
Example
- You revise hard for a maths mock and still get a grade 4. A growth mindset says the revision method needs fixing, so you change tactics and try again.
- A fixed mindset says maths is just not your subject, so you quietly stop trying to protect yourself from another blow.
How Mindset Drives Motivation and Effort
- A growth mindset raises effort, because you see effort as the route to getting better rather than a sign you are not naturally able.
- It also builds persistence, so you use feedback and keep going after a mistake instead of shutting down.
- A fixed mindset lowers effort, because trying hard and still failing would expose the lack of talent you fear.
- So fixed-mindset pupils often protect their image by not trying, which makes poor results more likely and appears to confirm the belief.
Note
- Dweck argues a mindset is not fixed for life, and the way adults praise a child can nudge it one way or the other.
The Role of Praise and Self-Efficacy
- Dweck found that the type of praise adults give pushes a child towards one mindset or the other.
- Praising effort and strategy, such as saying you worked hard and found a good method, builds a growth mindset.
- Praising ability, such as saying you are so clever, builds a fixed mindset, because the child then fears losing that label when work gets hard.
- Self-efficacy, your belief that you can succeed at a particular task, works alongside this: high self-efficacy raises effort and persistence and feeds a growth mindset, while low self-efficacy makes you give up sooner.
Evaluating Dweck's Theory
- The theory has had a huge influence on UK schools and is backed by intervention studies showing mindset can be taught.
- But real people are mixed, and the same pupil may hold a growth mindset in art yet a fixed one in maths.
- Large recent replications find the effect on grades is real but small, and strongest for disadvantaged or lower-attaining pupils.
- There is also a risk of a false growth mindset, where adults praise effort but never teach the better strategies that actually raise attainment.
Common Mistake
- Do not reduce a growth mindset to just trying hard; it is about using strategies and learning from feedback.
- Do not overstate the effect; note that studies show it is helpful but modest.
Explaining the Theory in an Answer
- Define the fixed and growth mindsets clearly.
- Explain how each one changes effort and the response to failure, and how praise can shape which one develops.
- Illustrate each with a pupil, then add one strength and one limitation.
Self review
- What is a fixed mindset?
- What is a growth mindset?
- How can the type of praise a child receives affect their mindset?
- Give one limitation of Dweck's mindset theory.