Sixty adult volunteers watch the same 90-second recording of a caretaker preparing a village hall for a meeting. No first-aid box appears in the recording.
The researchers randomly allocate 36 volunteers to read a summary containing the false statement that the caretaker placed a first-aid box beside the door. The other 24 volunteers read a matched summary containing no misleading information.
One week later, an interviewer who does not know which summary each volunteer read asks each volunteer to describe everything they remember. The interviewer then asks a recognition question about whether a first-aid box was present.
| Summary | Number of volunteers | Mentioned a first-aid box during open recall | Said that a first-aid box was present in the recognition question |
|---|---|---|---|
| Misleading | 36 | 12 | 21 |
| No misleading information | 24 | 2 | 6 |
The volunteers are told that the study concerns memory, that they may withdraw their data and that they will be fully debriefed immediately after the test.
Evaluate whether this study provides convincing evidence that the misleading summary created a false memory. Use the data in your answer and consider methodological and ethical issues.
81 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE Psychology 1.1 Memory, covering 1.1.1 Processes of memory, 1.1.2 Types of memory, 1.1.3 Multi-store model of memory, 1.1.4 Features of memory stores, 1.1.5 Primacy and recency effects, 1.1.6 Murdock's serial position study, 1.1.7 Theory of reconstructive memory, 1.1.8 Bartlett's War of the Ghosts study, and 1.1.9 Factors affecting accuracy of memory. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.