A researcher recruited 80 adults and randomly allocated 40 to each of two conditions. Everyone read the same ambiguous 220-word account of a person entering and spending time in an unfamiliar building. The account contained no hotel-specific details. Before reading it, one group saw the title ‘A hotel stay’ and the other group saw the title ‘A building visit’.
After 48 hours, participants recalled the account in writing. Two researchers independently used the same fixed coding scheme to identify up to six invented hotel details in each response. Both researchers knew which title each participant had seen.
| Title shown | Mean number of invented hotel details out of 6 | Agreement between the two researchers |
|---|---|---|
| A hotel stay | 3.8 | 62% |
| A building visit | 1.2 | 91% |
Evaluate this investigation as a test of reconstructive memory. In your answer, use the results, give one strength and one limitation, explain how the limitation could be addressed, and make a justified overall judgement.
81 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE Psychology 1.1 Memory, covering 1.1.1 Processes of memory, 1.1.2 Types of memory, 1.1.3 Multi-store model of memory, 1.1.4 Features of memory stores, 1.1.5 Primacy and recency effects, 1.1.6 Murdock's serial position study, 1.1.7 Theory of reconstructive memory, 1.1.8 Bartlett's War of the Ghosts study, and 1.1.9 Factors affecting accuracy of memory. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.