Tools for everyone?
Source A: an original account by an allotment holder.
When I took on an allotment, I made a shopping list: fork, hoe, shears, wheelbarrow. At the community lending shed, a volunteer crossed out my list and lent me three tools for the weekend. The hoe was too heavy; the shears were exactly right. By Monday, I knew what suited me without filling a cupboard with expensive mistakes.
Then, one bright Saturday, every wheelbarrow had been booked. I carried compost in two buckets and arrived at my plot with aching arms and very little patience. Shared tools replace expense with planning, not with magic. Even so, I would rather rearrange one Saturday than pay for an object that sleeps for six days each week.
Source B: an original account by a tool-lending coordinator.
I used to pin our monthly loan total above the desk as proof that the scheme was thriving. One resident borrowed the same tile cutter three times, returning it within an hour each time. I congratulated myself on another efficient loan. Eventually, he admitted that the instructions made no sense to him and he had been too embarrassed to ask.
We introduced short demonstrations and longer bookings. Our loan total fell, but more people finished their projects. However, when one borrower kept the cutter for a week, somebody else had to postpone a repair. We now offer an introduction and allow a renewal only when nobody is waiting. A generous scheme must be generous with explanation and careful with time.
Compare the ways in which each writer’s experiences lead them to a more complicated judgement about community tool-lending schemes. Refer to both sources in your answer.
140 exam-style questions on AQA GCSE English Language 3.1 Critical reading and comprehension, covering 3.1.1 Identify and interpret themes, ideas and information, 3.1.2 Read in different ways for different purposes, 3.1.3 Draw inferences and justify with evidence, 3.1.4 Support a point of view using textual evidence, 3.1.5 Identify bias and misuse of evidence, 3.1.6 Reflect critically and evaluatively using context, 3.1.7 Recognise different responses to a text, 3.1.8 Identify the main theme or themes, 3.1.9 Summarise ideas and information from a single text, 3.1.10 Synthesise from more than one text, 3.1.11 Explain how vocabulary and grammar create impact, 3.1.12 Analyse and evaluate form and structure, and 3.1.13 Compare texts critically. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.