Market structure describes the market, not the firm
Definition
Market structure: the way a market is organised, described by how many firms sell in it, how alike the things they sell are, and how easily a new firm can join.
- You classify a market, not a firm, so the subject is UK grocery selling or the supply of piped water rather than Tesco or Thames Water.
- The market has to be drawn before it can be placed, because the bread sellers in one town are a different market from the bread sellers in the whole UK.
- Structure is a continuum, so a market can be more competitive than one neighbour and less competitive than another without needing a box of its own.
- Where a market sits decides how much freedom a seller has over price, and every later point in this topic follows from that.
Key Idea
Structure is inherited rather than chosen. No firm decides whether its market has four sellers or four hundred; it finds the structure already there and has to behave accordingly.
UK markets span from tiny sellers to one supplier
- At the most competitive end almost anyone can start, so a British town supports dozens of window cleaners, gardeners and private tutors, none holding a share worth naming.
- A step along are markets with very many sellers whose products differ slightly, so hairdressers, cafes and takeaways keep a little loyalty from their regulars while still losing customers to a rival who is cheaper or nearer.
- Further along, a handful of large firms supply most of the output, as the big four supermarkets do in UK groceries and EE, O2, Vodafone and Three do in mobile networks.
- At the far end sits one firm, so a London household can buy piped water only from Thames Water, and only Network Rail owns the main-line track.
- Nothing forces a market to a round number of sellers, so the honest picture is a line with markets scattered along it rather than four boxes with one market in each.
Case study
- UK grocery selling shows the middle of the line, being neither a single seller nor a crowd of equals.
- Tesco alone takes between a quarter and a third of what British households spend on groceries, and Sainsbury's, Asda, Morrisons, Aldi and Lidl take most of the rest.
- Below them sit thousands of convenience shops, butchers, bakers and market stalls, so the market has a few very large sellers and a very long tail at the same time.
- That is why counting sellers gives the wrong answer here, and why the share held by the largest firms is the figure that places the market.
Entry, exit and mergers move a market's position
- Entry moves a market towards the competitive end, which is what Aldi and Lidl did to UK groceries by opening hundreds of stores and taking share from four firms that had been sharing it.
- Exit and merger move it the other way, because every seller that closes or is bought out leaves the survivors a larger slice of the same customers.
- Rules move markets, since opening the UK letters market to competitors in 2006 turned one legal supplier into several, and Royal Mail now carries most letters rather than all of them.
- Technology moves markets fastest, because a comparison website turns a market where buyers could not realistically compare sellers into one where they compare twenty in a minute, as happened in car insurance and household energy.
- A market's structure therefore has a date attached, so UK groceries as they were in 1990 are a different structure from UK groceries now.
Common Mistake
- Structure belongs to the market, not the firm: Tesco is huge but faces real rivals, while a small water company can be the only seller there is.
- Many sellers does not mean a competitive market: four firms can supply most of the output while thousands of small shops trade alongside them.
- A market does not stay where you last placed it: entry, exit, mergers, new rules and new technology all move it.
Placing a market on the line comes first
- The position decides how much freedom a seller has over price, which is why the same rise in energy costs is passed straight to customers in one market and swallowed by the seller in another.
- It also decides how much choice a buyer has, since the number of sellers is the number of alternatives a buyer can turn to.
- Name the position before making any judgement, because the same change can transform one structure and change nothing at all in another.
The factors that make the placing precise are section 1.5.1b. What a market at the competitive end looks like from the inside is 1.5.2a, and what happens at the concentrated end is 1.5.3.
Self review
- What does market structure describe, and what is the unit being described?
- Name a UK market near the competitive end of the range, and say why it sits there.
- Name a UK market supplied by a single firm, and say why a newcomer cannot enter it.
- Why is the share held by the largest firms more useful than the number of firms?
- Name two things that move a market along the range over time.