Three factors place a market's structure
Definition
Product differentiation: making a product seem different from a rival's, through branding, design, quality, packaging or the service that comes with it.
Barriers to entry: anything that makes it hard or expensive for a new firm to start selling in a market, such as the cost of the equipment, a licence, or a brand that buyers already trust.
- The number of producers is the first factor, and the question worth asking is what share the largest firms hold rather than how many names you can list.
- A market can contain thousands of sellers and still be concentrated when four of them supply most of the output.
- Market share puts a figure on it: market share=a firm’s salestotal market sales×100\text{market share} = \frac{\text{a firm's sales}}{\text{total market sales}} \times 100market share=total market salesa firm’s sales×100.
- The degree of product differentiation is the second, and it decides whether a buyer annoyed by a price rise has anywhere identical to go.
- It can be real, as with the engineering inside a car, or created, as with the packaging around two very similar shampoos.
- The more differentiated the product, the further a seller can hold its price above its rivals before the shop empties.
- The ease of entry is the third, and it decides whether a high profit in the market can last.
- Where entry is cheap, a visible profit brings newcomers who add to supply and pull the price back down.
- Where entry is blocked, the same profit simply sits there.
- The first two factors describe the market as it stands, and the third tells you whether it will stay that way.
Example
- A market's total sales for the year are £2,000 million, and the largest firm sells £560 million of that.
- The largest firm holds 28 per cent, a share big enough for its own pricing to move the whole market.
- The next three firms hold 15 per cent, 12 per cent and 9 per cent.
- The four largest firms hold 64 per cent between them, leaving 36 per cent shared among everybody else, however many sellers that turns out to be.
Ease of entry decides whether it lasts
- Start-up cost is the commonest barrier, so a window cleaner needs a ladder, a van and insurance while a new water company would need the mains already buried under London.
- Legal barriers block entry outright, since running trains on the main line, supplying tap water and broadcasting on a radio frequency all need permission that is not handed out on request.
- Control of a key input works the same way, because a firm that owns the only track, the only pipes or the only local quarry decides who else can trade.
- Economies of scale raise a quieter barrier, since a newcomer producing small volumes carries a higher cost per unit and so cannot match an established firm's price.
- Brand loyalty is a barrier built by spending, because a new soft drink has to be advertised for years before shoppers reach for it without thinking.
- Barriers to exit belong here too, since a firm that would lose everything it spent on premises and equipment thinks twice about entering at all.
Case study
- Two UK markets sit at opposite ends of the entry test.
- Window cleaning needs a ladder, a van, insurance and a round of customers, so a new cleaner can be working within a fortnight and no existing cleaner can stop them.
- Piped water in London needs the reservoirs, treatment works and buried mains that Thames Water already owns, and no household can be supplied without them.
- The number of producers follows from the barrier rather than the other way round, which is why one market has dozens of sellers and the other has exactly one.
A market must be scored on all three factors
- A market can pass on producers and fail on entry, as UK grocery selling does, because thousands of shops sell food while the land, depots and buying power a national chain needs keep new national rivals out.
- It can pass on producers and fail on differentiation, as branded soft drinks do, because there are many producers and yet plenty of shoppers will not swap one cola for another on price alone.
- It can look concentrated on producers and still behave competitively on price, as UK groceries did while Aldi and Lidl were taking share, because a small number of large firms can still fight each other hard.
- It can fail all three at once, as regional water supply does, with one producer, no substitute and no possible entrant.
- The verdict comes from reading the three answers together, so a market counts as competitive only when many producers, weak differentiation and easy entry all hold at once.
Example
- Five UK markets scored against the three factors.
| Market | Producers | Differentiation | Entry |
|---|---|---|---|
| Window cleaning | Dozens in a town | Almost none | Very easy |
| Hairdressing | Tens of thousands | Some, from skill and location | Easy |
| UK groceries | A few chains plus many small shops | Some, from own-label and location | Hard nationally, easy locally |
| Mobile networks | Four operators | Some, from coverage and contracts | Very hard |
| Regional water | One | None | Blocked |
- Competition falls down the table as differentiation and the difficulty of entry rise together, which is the pattern the three factors exist to reveal.
When all three factors agree, the label follows
- Many producers, weak differentiation and easy entry describe a competitive market, and no seller in one has much freedom over its price.
- A few large producers, some differentiation and hard entry describe a concentrated market, where the largest sellers do have that freedom.
- One producer, no close substitute and blocked entry describe a monopoly, the far end of the range.
- The label is only shorthand for the three answers, so an answer that gives the three answers has earned more than one that gives the label alone.
What a competitive market looks like from the inside is section 1.5.2a. The concentrated end, including monopoly and oligopoly, is section 1.5.3.
Exam technique
- Turn the number of producers into a market share wherever figures are given, showing the division and the multiplication by 100.
- Score every market on all three factors, not just the one that gives the easiest answer.
Self review
- Name the three factors used to distinguish between market structures.
- A firm sells £560 million in a market whose total sales are £2,000 million: what is its market share?
- Give two barriers to entry, and say why each keeps new firms out.
- Why can a market with thousands of sellers still be concentrated?
- What does product differentiation let a seller do that a seller of an identical product cannot?