Consumers gain most: lower prices, choice and quality
- Price is the gain consumers notice first, because a firm charging above its rivals in a market of close substitutes simply loses the sale.
- The gain is real income rather than a bookkeeping saving, since a household whose weekly shop falls by £5 has £5 to spend on something else.
- Choice widens because a large number of sellers means a large number of versions, locations, opening hours and ways to pay.
- Quality and service improve for the same reason the price falls, as they are what a firm reaches for once it cannot undercut anybody.
- Consumers also gain from innovation they never asked for, because a firm hunting for an edge brings out the cheaper method or the better product first.
- The gains are not spread evenly, since a shopper with a car and a phone can compare and travel while one with neither pays whatever the nearest seller charges.
Producers gain efficiency but lose a comfortable margin
- The gain is that competition forces waste out, so a firm that survives it is leaner than it would otherwise have been and better placed to compete elsewhere.
- Competition can also grow the market, since a lower price sells more units and an efficient firm can end up larger than it would have grown behind a quiet life.
- The cost is that the amount earned on each unit is competed away, leaving very little cushion for a bad year.
- A thin margin also leaves less retained profit for research, new equipment and training, so an industry can be cheap this year and slow to improve over a decade.
- Some firms do not survive the pressure at all, and every closure destroys the value of what the owners put in.
- Small producers are squeezed hardest, because they cannot get the bulk prices, borrowing terms or advertising reach that a large rival takes for granted.
- The squeeze passes up the supply chain, which is why the price a British dairy farmer receives for milk can fall at the same time as the shop price.
- Competition is not simply good or bad for producers: the pressure that removes their margin also removes their waste.
- Not every producer feels it equally: a national chain and a single farm face the same market price with completely different bargaining power.
Workers feel competition through both jobs and pay
- Competition creates jobs where the winning firms expand, so the hundreds of stores Aldi and Lidl opened in Britain came with thousands of new jobs attached.
- It destroys jobs where the losing firms contract, so the same years brought superstore closures, counter closures and head office cuts at the chains losing share.
- Because labour is usually the largest cost a firm can actually control, a firm cutting costs looks early at pay, hours and staffing levels, which shows up as fewer staff on a shop floor and more flexible contracts.
- Workers gain as consumers at the same time, since a pay packet buys more when prices fall, so the effect on a household is not the same as the effect on its wages.
- Competition also raises productivity, and output per worker is what makes higher real pay affordable, so much depends on whether a firm competes by working smarter or by paying less.
- Where the skill a firm needs is scarce, competition between employers pushes those workers' pay up, so competition does not press on every worker in the same direction.
- UK grocery selling over the last twenty years shows all three groups at once.
- Consumers gained, as the discounters forced hundreds of everyday prices down and the established chains matched them rather than lose shoppers.
- Producers divided, with Aldi and Lidl growing to close to a fifth of the market between them while Asda and Morrisons lost share and were both sold.
- Workers saw both sides, with thousands of jobs created in new discount stores and thousands lost as counters, night shifts and head office roles were cut elsewhere.
- Suppliers felt it too, as farmers and food manufacturers were pressed for lower prices by buyers who were themselves under pressure.
Profits stay low because nothing protects a margin
Profit margin: the profit a firm makes on each unit it sells, which is the price of that unit minus the cost of producing it.
- The price is pulled down towards the cost of producing each unit, because a firm asking for more than that loses buyers to a close substitute they can both see and reach.
- Easy entry finishes the job, since a visible margin is an open invitation to outsiders and every newcomer adds to supply and pushes the price down again, which is why no firm here can hold its price above cost for long.
- The mechanism runs in reverse too, so when firms make losses some leave, supply falls and the price recovers, which is why the margin hovers near cost rather than sinking far below it.
- A competitive firm also cannot recover a cost increase by raising its price, so a rise in wages or energy costs lands on the margin rather than on the customer.
- Where a small number of producers dominate, none of that applies, because entry is hard, substitutes are poor and buyers have fewer places to go, so a higher price and a wider margin survive year after year.
- The difference is protection rather than effort, since the sheltered firms are not working harder for their higher profit.
- A tin costs £1.05 to produce and put on a shelf.
- In a competitive market it sells for £1.20, so the margin is 15p.
- Where a small number of producers dominate, the same tin sells for £1.50, so the margin is 45p.
- The cost has not changed, so the gap between 12.5 per cent and 30 per cent is the margin competition would have removed.
- On 20 million tins a year the competitive firm still takes £3 million on this one line, so a thin margin is not a small profit.
How gains and costs balance depends on the market
- It depends on how easily new firms can enter, because a market protected by heavy set-up costs keeps its margin however many names appear on the shelf.
- It depends on whether consumers have good information, since a saving no shopper can find disciplines nobody, while a comparison that takes seconds on a phone disciplines every seller at once.
- It depends on whether the pressure falls on wages or on efficiency, because a firm that reorganises its work passes nothing on to its staff, while one that cuts hours and pay moves the whole cost onto them.
- It depends on the time horizon, as the lower price arrives within months while the lost retained profit for research and equipment only shows up over a decade.
- It depends on how far the shake-out runs, because competition that leaves only two or three sellers ends by destroying the rivalry that produced the gain in the first place.
Judgement: in markets like groceries and air travel the consumer gain has been large, visible and spread across every household, while the losses have been concentrated on particular firms and particular jobs, so competition is usually worth having, provided entry stays genuinely open and the pressure on pay and conditions is held back by law rather than left entirely to the market.
These effects are covered in later sections
How competitive pressure feeds into economic growth and inflation is covered in Paper 2 (2.2.2 and 2.2.4), and how a small number of producers behave when that pressure is absent is section 1.5.3.
- Answer for all three groups the spec names, consumers, producers and workers.
- Explain the lower profits through the mechanism: close substitutes and easy entry drive price down towards cost, unlike in a market dominated by a small number of producers.
- Give two ways consumers gain from competition, and one reason a particular consumer might not.
- Give one gain and one cost of competition for producers.
- How does competition affect workers, and why can the effect run either way?
- Why are profits likely to be lower in a competitive market than in one dominated by a small number of producers?
- A tin costs £1.05 to produce and sells for £1.20: what is the margin as a percentage of the price?