Firms here take the price they are given
Definition
Price taker: a firm that is too small a part of its market to affect the market price, so it has to sell at the going rate or not sell at all.
Price maker: a firm large enough, or sheltered enough, to choose its own price and still keep its customers.
- The conditions set out in section 1.5.2a are what make a firm a price taker, so this article starts where that one finished.
- A price taker can still change its price, but both directions are unattractive: charging more loses the customers, while charging less wins sales at a margin that may not cover the trouble.
- Charging more fails because the buyer has a close substitute and can see the price, so the custom lost outweighs the extra earned on each remaining sale.
- Charging less works for a fortnight, until rivals selling the same thing match it and the whole market settles at the lower price with nobody better off.
- What is left are the decisions the firm genuinely controls, its costs, quality, service, range and rate of innovation, and competitive behaviour is the sum of those.
Example
- Six sandwich shops on one street sell a filled roll at about £3.50.
- One raises its price to £4.20, keeps its regulars but loses the office workers who buy on price, and takes less money by the end of the week despite earning more on each roll.
- Another cuts to £3.20 and is busy for a fortnight, until four of the others cut to £3.20 as well and the queue returns to normal at a lower price.
- A third leaves its price alone, moves its bread onto a bulk contract, and ends up charging what everyone else charges while keeping more of it.
- The third shop is the one behaving the way a competitive market rewards.
Holding costs down becomes a condition of survival
- With the price fixed by the market, the only way to widen the gap between price and cost is to push the cost of each unit down.
- A firm whose cost per unit sits above its rivals' cannot pass the difference on, so it comes out of profit until there is no profit left to take it from.
- Firms therefore buy in bulk, cut waste, open for longer hours and replace labour with machinery wherever the machine is cheaper.
- Aldi and Lidl take the strategy to its limit, stocking a few thousand lines rather than tens of thousands, displaying goods in the boxes they arrived in, and printing barcodes on several faces of a package so it scans from any angle.
- Greggs reaches the same end from the other direction, baking and finishing at a small number of large sites so the cost of each sausage roll falls as the volume through those sites rises.
- The pressure is permanent rather than occasional, because a saving one firm finds is copied by the others and the going price then falls to reflect it.
Case study
- UK grocery selling shows a whole market pushed into cost cutting by two entrants.
- Aldi and Lidl grew to close to a fifth of British grocery spending between them, selling a narrow range at prices the established chains could not match on their existing costs.
- Tesco and Sainsbury's answered with price-match schemes pegging hundreds of everyday items to Aldi's prices, which only works if their own costs come down far enough to fund it.
- All of them trimmed ranges, closed in-store counters, moved shoppers onto self-service checkouts and pressed suppliers for lower prices.
- Asda and Morrisons, slower to cut costs, lost share and were both sold, which is the punishment a competitive market hands out.
Quality, service and range replace price competition
- Once every seller is near the same price, the only way to hold a customer is to be better rather than cheaper.
- Quality is the first lever, so a supermarket builds a tiered own-label range and a baker advertises where the ingredients came from.
- Service is the second, covering opening hours, delivery slots, click and collect, returns and how quickly a complaint is settled.
- Range is the third, because the shop that stocks the one item a shopper cannot find elsewhere wins the whole basket rather than just that item.
- Loyalty schemes sit between price and service, since Tesco Clubcard prices and Sainsbury's Nectar prices cut the bill only for shoppers who keep coming back.
- None of it is free, and all of it comes out of the same thin margin, which is why a competitive firm is constantly trading one of these against another.
Common Mistake
- Competitive firms do not compete on price alone: quality, service and range take most of the effort once prices have converged.
- A firm cannot cover a cost rise by raising its price, unless every rival faces the same rise at the same time.
- Advertising is not proof of market power: a seller of a close substitute advertises simply to be remembered.
Innovation is forced, and its reward is temporary
- A firm that finds a cheaper method or a better product takes sales from its rivals, which is the only way a price taker gets ahead of them at all.
- The advantage lasts only until the rivals copy it, since nothing in a competitive market stops them, so the saving ends up with buyers as a lower price.
- The pressure to innovate therefore never eases, because standing still means falling behind the moment somebody else moves.
- Advertising follows the same logic, as a firm selling something close to identical has to keep its name in front of buyers or lose them to whoever they happened to think of first.
- Entering and leaving are behaviour too, so firms move in when profits look good and out when they do not, and that movement drags the price back towards cost.
What all of this behaviour does to consumers, producers and workers, and why the profits it leaves behind are thin, is section 1.5.2c.
Exam technique
- Label each example as price or non-price competition, since a question often asks for one and not the other.
- Keep the impact on consumers, producers and workers out of this answer, as that is a separate spec point.
Self review
- What is a price taker, and how does it differ from a price maker?
- Why does raising the price above rivals usually reduce a firm's total takings?
- Why can a firm in a competitive market not pass a cost increase on to its customers?
- Give two ways a firm competes for customers without changing its price.
- Why does the advantage from an innovation last only a short time here?