Profit decides whether a producer bothers at all
Definition
Profit motive: the drive to earn the largest possible surplus of revenue over costs, which is what decides whether a private firm supplies a good at all and how much of it.
- Nobody in a market economy is obliged to produce anything, so something has to make it worth a producer's while to commit resources.
- That something has to be substantial, because a producer takes a risk, paying wages, rent and materials before knowing whether the output will sell.
- Profit is also the source of the money for expansion, since profit kept back in the business pays for extra machines, vans or premises without borrowing.
- Loss making activity cannot go on indefinitely, because the owner is covering the shortfall out of savings or debt.
- The strength of the incentive depends on the size of the gap between price and cost per unit, which is why the same firm expands one product line while closing another.
How total costs, total revenue and profit are calculated is 1.4.1b and 1.4.1c; this section takes those figures as given.
A higher price widens profit if costs hold steady
- A higher price means more total revenue from exactly the same quantity sold, because every unit now brings in more money.
- If the cost of producing a unit is unchanged, all of that extra revenue becomes extra profit per unit, which is the price minus the cost of producing a unit and exactly the number a producer looks at.
- A modest rise in price can multiply profit per unit several times over, because what widens is the narrow gap between price and cost rather than the price itself.
- The condition matters as much as the chain, because a price rise that is caused by rising costs leaves the gap no wider and brings no extra output.
Example
- A dairy farmer: the farm gate milk price is £0.35 a litre, it costs £0.32 a litre to produce, and the herd yields 900,000 litres a year.
- The price then rises to £0.45 a litre while feed, labour and vet costs stay where they were.
- A price rise of about 29 per cent has turned £27,000 into £117,000, which is why the farmer now thinks about adding cows rather than selling them.
Wider profit per unit is why supply slopes upward
- Expanding output costs money, so a producer only does it when the extra revenue expected is bigger than the extra cost.
- A wider gap between price and cost per unit means more of the expensive extra output becomes worth making, such as overtime shifts, older machines or poorer land.
- Overtime is paid at a higher hourly rate, so an extra hour is only worth buying when the price of the output covers it.
- Existing firms therefore raise the quantity supplied as price rises, and new firms enter because the higher price now covers the cost of setting up.
- Expansion also takes time, since planting a crop, training staff, restocking a flock or building a factory cannot be done in the week the price moves.
- A higher price only widens profit per unit if costs are unchanged.
Case study
- UK electricity, 2021 to 2023: wholesale prices rose sharply, and developers brought forward solar farms and battery storage while North Sea operators reworked fields that had not been worth producing at the old price.
- Eggs: UK egg prices rose through 2022 and 2023 after producers had cut their flocks, and it was the higher price that persuaded them to restock the sheds.
- In every case the extra output followed the price rather than causing it, which is the direction the exam is testing.
Falling profit runs the chain backwards
- Firms cut output first, by ending overtime, dropping a shift or running one production line instead of three.
- Exit comes last, when the price no longer covers costs at any output the firm can produce, as it did for the nearly thirty small UK energy suppliers that failed in 2021 and 2022 while the Ofgem price cap held their price below the wholesale cost they were paying.
Self review
- What is meant by the profit motive?
- A firm sells at £0.45 a unit and its cost per unit is £0.32, so what is its profit per unit?
- Why does a higher price raise profit per unit only if costs are unchanged?
- Explain why the profit incentive makes the supply curve slope upwards.
- Give one UK example of a price rise that brought extra output.