Firms with power set their own price
What makes a market non-competitive, and the barriers to entry that keep it that way, is section 1.5.3a. This section is about what the firms inside it then do.
- A firm in a competitive market is a price taker, so it sells at the going rate or watches its customers walk to a rival.
- A firm in a non-competitive market is a price maker, so it chooses its price and the market tells it only how many units it will sell at that price.
- The power comes from the buyer's lack of an alternative, because someone who refuses the price has to go without rather than buy the same thing elsewhere.
- Even so, the firm faces a demand curve that slopes downwards, so a higher price always costs it some sales and pricing stays a trade-off rather than a free hand.
- Where a few large firms share a market, each also has to judge how the others will react before it moves, which is why prices there often move together and change rarely.
Case study
- Energy: the big six energy firms raised and cut household tariffs in close step for years, which is one reason Ofgem imposed a price cap.
- Letter post: Royal Mail sets the price of a first class stamp, and a household that thinks it dear has no second letter service to switch to.
- Water: Thames Water charges the bill its regulator allows, because nobody in its region can buy mains water from anyone else.
- Rail track: train operators negotiate access charges with Network Rail rather than shopping around, since there is only one network to run trains on.
Restricting output keeps the price up
- A seller facing no serious rival can supply less than the market would take, because a smaller quantity on sale leaves buyers bidding the price up.
- The chain runs from less output, to a shortage relative to what buyers want, to a higher price, to a larger profit on every unit sold.
- Output therefore tends to be lower and price higher than the same market would produce with many sellers in it, and buyers who would have bought at the lower price go without altogether.
- A firm can hold the price up without cutting production at all, simply by adding new capacity slowly, releasing flights, homes or broadband connections at a pace that keeps the price where it wants it.
- With a few large firms the same result can appear without anybody planning it, if each quietly avoids the price cut that would start a price war it could not win.
Branding and advertising make the product harder to compare
- Product differentiation is the second lever, because the less like a rival's product a good seems, the less a buyer switches over a small price difference.
- Heavy advertising builds that difference in the buyer's mind even where the goods themselves are close, and the brand loyalty it creates then doubles as a barrier to entry.
- Loyalty schemes such as Tesco Clubcard prices and Nectar prices tie the shopper to one seller, because the advertised saving is only there for people who stop comparing across shops.
- Firms also differentiate through service, adding next-day delivery, longer guarantees or app-based accounts, and each addition is another reason not to leave.
- Competition here therefore runs mostly on advertising, branding and range rather than price, which is called non-price competition, and it raises the firm's costs as well as its sales, with those costs recovered from the buyer in the price.
Example
- The identical line: Tesco and Sainsbury's both sell a standard tin of baked beans, and because the tins are almost the same neither can charge much more than the other.
- The differentiated line: each chain also sells its own premium range in its own packaging, which a shopper cannot buy in the other shop.
- The premium line carries a much larger margin, because there is nothing exactly equivalent on the other shelf to compare it with.
- So competition on the identical lines stays fierce while competition on the differentiated lines is much weaker, in the very same shop.
Without competitive pressure, costs drift and innovation slows
- A firm that cannot lose its customers has less reason to cut its costs, because its profit does not depend on being the cheapest producer in the market.
- Costs then drift upwards through overstaffing, careless purchasing and tolerated waste, and a comfortable profit hides the problem.
- The incentive to innovate weakens for the same reason, since a firm with no rival gains little from making its own product obsolete.
- Service quality slips where customers cannot leave, which is why complaints about water companies, rail operators and broadband providers have so often outlasted promises to improve.
- The counter-argument matters, because a protected firm has the profits to fund research, can plan long projects knowing no rival will undercut it, and may have a cost per unit no small firm could match.
- Whether the money is actually spent on research, and whether that lower cost reaches the price, depends on the firm, and that is what a judgement on market power turns on in section 1.5.3c.
Common Mistake
- These firms do not stop competing: they compete on advertising, branding, loyalty schemes and service instead of price.
- A large firm is not automatically inefficient: economies of scale can make it the lowest-cost producer.
- Do not stop at prices are higher: run the chain on to output, choice and the buyers who go without.
Consumer choice narrows in ways shoppers notice
- Choice narrows first in the number of sellers, so a buyer unhappy with the price or the service has nowhere else to take their money.
- Choice narrows again in the range on offer, because one firm decides which products exist and drops the lines that suit only a small group of buyers.
- Rural areas feel this most sharply, since a bus route, bank branch or fibre connection that is unprofitable for the one supplier is simply not provided.
- Where a few firms differentiate heavily the shelves can look full of choice while the number of genuine alternatives on price stays small.
- Switching costs deepen the problem, as contracts, exit fees and complicated tariffs keep buyers where they are even when a better offer exists.
- The overall effect on consumers is a higher price, a narrower range and weaker pressure on quality, and how far scale and investment offset that is section 1.5.3c.
Self review
- What is the difference between a price maker and a price taker?
- Explain how restricting output raises the price.
- What is non-price competition? Give two examples.
- Why does a firm here face less pressure to cut its costs?
- Give two ways consumer choice narrows in a non-competitive market.