Externalities are the costs or benefits markets miss
Private cost: the cost of an activity paid by the person or firm carrying it out, such as wages, fuel, materials and rent.
Private benefit: the gain from an activity enjoyed by the person or firm carrying it out, such as a firm's revenue or a consumer's satisfaction.
Social cost: the total cost of an activity to society, which is the private cost plus any cost falling on everybody else.
Social benefit: the total benefit of an activity to society, which is the private benefit plus any benefit enjoyed by everybody else.
Externality: the difference between the social figure and the private figure, which is the cost or benefit of an activity that lands on a third party rather than on the buyer or the seller.
- The two private figures are the only ones a buyer or a seller consults, because they are the only ones that actually land on the person making the decision.
- The two social figures put everybody else back in, so they measure what the activity does to the whole community rather than to the two people trading.
- The relationship is an addition on each side: social cost = private cost + external cost and social benefit = private benefit + external benefit.
- Rearranging either identity gives the externality directly, since it is whatever is left when the private figure is taken away from the social one.
A third party is affected outside the deal
- Every transaction has exactly two parties, the buyer and the seller, and everything the two of them weigh up is private by definition.
- A third party is anybody else who is affected by that transaction without having bought, sold or agreed to it.
- The third party has no way to send a bill for the harm or to charge for the benefit, so nothing about them ever reaches the price.
- That silence is what makes the market's arithmetic incomplete, because the price is adding up a genuine total but not the total that matters to society.
- A haulage firm's private cost of one delivery run is £400 in fuel, wages and wear on the lorry.
- The exhaust fumes, noise and road damage that the run creates are valued at £90 by the people who live along the route.
- Adding the private cost and the external cost gives the social cost:
- The externality is the £90 difference, which the firm never pays and the delivery price never shows.
The same gap can open up on benefits
- Everything above works identically for benefits, with the gap sitting between the social benefit and the private benefit instead of between the two costs.
- A household that insulates its loft counts the lower heating bill, while the country gains lower national energy demand and lower emissions that never enter the household's decision.
- Because the decision counts only the private half, less insulation is fitted than society would have chosen.
- The direction of the gap tells you which way the market went wrong, since a social cost above the private cost means too much was produced, while a social benefit above the private benefit means too little was consumed.
- Social cost is not the harm to others: it is the private cost plus that harm.
- The externality is the difference between the two totals, never a total in its own right.
- Private benefit is not only profit: for a consumer it is the satisfaction they get from the good.
Often private and social figures already match
- Most transactions create no externality, so both identities collapse to equalities and the market price already tells the whole story.
- A haircut, a loaf of bread or a pair of shoes affects only the buyer and the seller, which is why nobody proposes taxing or subsidising them.
- Externalities are therefore about the minority of markets where somebody outside the deal is affected and no price is ever charged for it.
Whether that gap leaves third parties better or worse off, and whether it arises in production or in consumption, is classified in 1.6.2b.
- Write the identity linking social cost, private cost and external cost.
- Who counts as a third party in a transaction?
- A run costs a firm £400 and imposes £90 on residents, so what is the social cost and what is the externality?
- Why does a third party's loss never show up in the market price?
- What does it tell you when social benefit is greater than private benefit?