Related goods are alternatives or pairs
Definition
Substitute goods: goods a buyer can use in place of one another to meet the same want, so buying one normally means not buying the other.
Complementary goods: goods a buyer uses together, so buying one makes buying the other more likely.
- The link lives in the buyer's use of the two goods rather than in the goods themselves, so the same pair can be related for one household and unrelated for another.
- An exam question may use the other names, calling substitutes goods in competitive demand and complements goods in joint demand.
- Either link comes in degrees rather than as a yes or no, so a pair can be closely or only loosely linked.
- Two jars of instant coffee on the same Tesco shelf are close substitutes, because they do practically the same job.
- Coffee and orange juice are weak substitutes, because only a few drinkers would swap one for the other at breakfast.
- A games console and its games are tightly complementary, while strawberries and cream are only loosely so.
- Most pairs of goods are neither, so bread and shoelaces are simply unrelated, and spotting that is as much a part of the skill as spotting a link.
Test it with a price rise
- Take the two goods, imagine the price of the first one rising, and ask what happens to demand for the second.
- If demand for the second good rises, the two are substitutes, because buyers put off by the dearer good have moved across to the alternative.
- If demand for the second good falls, the two are complements, because buyers cutting back on the dearer good need less of its partner as well.
- If demand for the second good does not move at all, the two goods are unrelated.

Common Mistake
- Bought in the same trip is not a complement: used together means used to do one job.
- Made by rival firms is not a substitute: Nissan and a bakery chain compete for nobody's custom.
- A cheaper version is not a substitute: a smaller loaf is still the same product.
Named UK pairs, side by side
- The clearest substitutes are two versions of the same thing sold beside each other, and the clearest complements are two things that only work as a pair.
- Reading a pair aloud with the words instead of and then as well as usually settles it, because only one of the two phrases makes sense of the pair.
- Unrelated pairs belong in the same table, because a question often includes one to check that the link is being tested rather than assumed.
Example
- Some examples are given below
| Pair | Link | Behaviour |
|---|---|---|
| Heinz beans, Tesco beans | Substitute | One tin, not both |
| Printer, ink | Complement | Buys ink repeatedly |
| Nissan Leaf, petrol | Unrelated | Never buys petrol |
- Testing the first row, dearer Heinz sends some shoppers to the own-label tin, so demand for it rises and the pair are substitutes.
- The same logic covers the rest of the table!
Borderline pairs turn on the buyer's use
- A pair can be substitutes for one buyer and unrelated for another, so a rail season ticket and a car are alternatives for a Leeds commuter but not for somebody who works from home.
- A pair can also change category as technology changes, since a DVD and a streaming subscription only became substitutes once streaming existed in UK homes.
- The same product can even sit on both sides of the line depending on the use in question.
- A mobile phone and a landline are substitutes for making a call, since one call goes down one line or the other.
- A mobile phone and a data plan are complements, since the phone cannot do most of its job without the data.
- Where a pair really is borderline, say which use you are assuming and then answer, because the marks are for the reasoning rather than for the label.
Self review
- What is a substitute good, and what is a complementary good?
- Which term goes with joint demand, and which with competitive demand?
- Are a printer and its ink cartridges substitutes or complements, and why?
- State the test that tells you which link a pair of goods has.
- Why are two jars of instant coffee closer substitutes than coffee and orange juice?