A student studies records for two pairs of elements in Mendeleev's periodic table.
| Pair of elements | Relative atomic masses | Chemical observations | Sequence chosen by Mendeleev | Proton numbers measured later |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| cobalt and nickel | cobalt: 58.9; nickel: 58.7 | cobalt matched the reactions and compound formulae of elements in an earlier column; nickel matched those in the next column | cobalt, then nickel | 27, then 28 |
| tellurium and iodine | tellurium: 127.6; iodine: 126.9 | tellurium matched the reactions and compound formulae of elements in an earlier column; iodine matched those in the next column | tellurium, then iodine | 52, then 53 |
The student makes this claim:
"These records show that chemical behaviour should have replaced relative atomic mass as the main rule for arranging all the elements."
Evaluate the student's claim.
101 exam-style questions on Edexcel GCSE Chemistry 2.2 The periodic table, covering 2.2.1 Mendeleev's periodic table, 2.2.2 Periods, groups, metals and non-metals, and 2.2.3 Electronic configuration and position in the periodic table. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.