Minimising risk: testing the idea on paper before the money is spent
Risk: the chance that a business decision loses money, for example that sales come in far below the level the owner expected.
- Planning cuts risk because the idea is tested on paper first, where a wrong assumption costs nothing to correct, and four parts of the plan do that work.
- Revenue and cost forecasts: setting expected sales against expected fixed and variable costs shows whether the idea can make a profit at all, before a single pound goes on stock.
- The cash-flow forecast: it shows the month the balance turns negative, so an overdraft can be arranged in advance instead of in a panic during the week the rent is due.
- Market research inside the plan: asking 200 people in the area whether they would buy tests that customers exist, which cuts the chance of filling a shop with stock nobody wants.
- Objectives with figures and dates: a target of £4,000 of sales a month gives something to measure actual takings against, so a shortfall shows up in month two while it is still fixable.
- A bakery in Leeds whose plan shows January takings falling to £2,100 against rent of £900 a month knows in October that an overdraft will be needed, and a lender approached calmly in October is far more likely to agree than one approached in January.
- Planning reduces risk, it does not remove it.
- Every figure in a plan is a forecast, and a forecast is a considered guess about a market that has not happened yet.
- What changes is that the owner is surprised by fewer things, and has already decided what to do when a surprise comes.
Obtaining finance: the plan is the evidence a lender asks for
- A bank or an investor parts with money only if it believes the money is coming back, and the business plan is the evidence behind that belief.
- A lender reads the plan for three things.
- How much is needed and what for: £15,000 for a second-hand oven, a shop refit and three months of stock can be checked, while £15,000 to get started cannot.
- When it can be repaid: the cash-flow forecast shows the monthly surplus the repayments would come out of, so the lender can judge whether £400 a month is realistic.
- Whether the owner understands the market: the research and competitor sections show whether they know who buys, at what price and against whom, which decides whether they are trusted with the money.
- Without a plan a lender has only an idea and a request for money, so most will refuse, and that falls hardest on a start-up because it has no trading record to offer instead.
- Levi Roots took Reggae Reggae Sauce to Dragons' Den in 2007 and left with £50,000 of investment.
- The sauce was then stocked by Sainsbury's.
- An investor is buying a share of future profits, so what has to convince is the route to those profits, and that route is what a plan sets out.
Judging how much a business plan is really worth
- A plan can reduce risk and help a start-up obtain finance, but its forecasts may be wrong or over-optimistic because they are based on estimates rather than actual trading results.
- Its value therefore depends on honest assumptions and regular updates as real sales, costs and market changes replace the original forecasts.
- Overall, a current plan is useful evidence for decisions and finance, while following an outdated plan rigidly can make the business keep spending on assumptions it already knows are wrong.
- Keep the two purposes separate: minimising risk and obtaining finance.
- For risk, show how a forecast lets the owner spot a problem and act before it happens; for finance, explain what evidence reassures the lender or investor.
- For a judgement, consider how reliable and up to date the forecasts are rather than treating the plan as automatically accurate.
- Name the two purposes of a business plan in this specification.
- How does a cash-flow forecast inside a plan reduce risk?
- What does a lender want the plan to prove before agreeing to a loan?
- Why does planning reduce risk rather than remove it?
- Give one reason a plan can mislead the owner who wrote it.