Two sealed bags made from a partially permeable membrane contain equal volumes of the same concentrated sugar solution. One bag has a surface area of 20 cm2 and the other has a surface area of 40 cm2.
Both bags are placed in pure water for 30 minutes. Before the final mass is measured, the smaller bag is gently blotted with a paper towel but the larger bag is weighed with water still on its outside.
Why cannot a valid conclusion about the effect of surface area be made?
blotting the smaller bag could remove water from inside it and reduce its mass increase
water moves out of both bags into the pure water, so neither bag can increase in mass
the two bags have different surface areas, so their mass increases cannot be fairly compared
water left on the outside of the unblotted bag could be counted as part of its mass increase
88 exam-style questions on Edexcel GCSE Biology 1.4 Transport across cell membranes, covering 1.4.1 Transport into and out of cells and 1.4.2 Percentage gain and loss in osmosis. Each one has a worked solution and a mark scheme showing where the marks go.