Why fruit is used
DNA
The polymer that carries the genetic code, made of two nucleotide strands coiled into a double helix.
- DNA can be extracted from any tissue whose cells contain nuclei, and soft fruit is the usual starting material because it is easy to work with at the bench.
- Fruit tissue is soft, so it is broken up by mashing alone, without the grinding or heating that tougher tissue would need.
- The cells of the fruit are packed closely together and each one holds a nucleus, so even a few grams of tissue contains a very large number of nuclei and therefore a large amount of DNA.
- Strawberries and kiwi fruit work particularly well, because their cells contain several sets of chromosomes rather than the two sets found in a human body cell.
- Each extra set is a further copy of the same DNA, so a given mass of strawberry tissue yields more DNA than the same mass of most other tissue.
- Fruit is also cheap, safe to handle and needs no preservation, so the whole extraction can be done in a single lesson with everyday materials.
A strawberry cell carries several sets of chromosomes, so a few grams of mashed fruit holds enough DNA for the extracted threads to be seen with the naked eye.
Barriers around DNA
- In a fruit cell the DNA is held inside the nucleus, which is enclosed by its own membrane.
- The nucleus sits in the cytoplasm, and the cytoplasm is enclosed by the cell surface membrane.
- Outside the cell surface membrane there is a rigid cell wall made of cellulose, which gives the plant cell its strength.
- Four layers therefore lie between the DNA and the outside of the cell: the cell wall, the cell surface membrane, the cytoplasm and the membrane around the nucleus.
- Every step of the extraction method exists either to remove one of these layers or to separate the released DNA from everything else that comes out of the cell with it.
- The cell wall is broken by physical force, the two membranes are broken down chemically, and the DNA is then separated from the liquid it has dissolved in.
Extracting DNA from strawberries
- Aim: to extract DNA from strawberry tissue and see it as white threads, using detergent and salt to release the DNA and ice-cold ethanol to bring it out of solution.
- Apparatus: two or three ripe strawberries with the green tops pulled off, a self-seal plastic bag or a pestle and mortar, table salt, washing-up liquid, distilled water, a beaker and stirring rod for the extraction buffer, a measuring cylinder, a filter funnel with filter paper or a piece of muslin, a boiling tube and rack, ice-cold ethanol from a freezer, a glass rod, eye protection.
- Method:
- Make up the extraction buffer first: dissolve about 3 g3\,\text{g}3g of table salt in distilled water in a beaker, add 10 cm310\,\text{cm}^310cm3 of washing-up liquid, and make the volume up to 100 cm3100\,\text{cm}^3100cm3, stirring slowly so that no froth forms.
- Put about 10 g10\,\text{g}10g of strawberry into the plastic bag, seal it with air pushed out, and mash it with your fingers for 222 minutes until no lumps are left, because this physical mashing is what breaks the cellulose cell walls and releases the cell contents.
- Add about 10 cm310\,\text{cm}^310cm3 of the buffer to the bag, seal it again and squash gently for another minute, keeping the movement slow so the detergent does not froth up.
- Stand the bag or beaker still for 151515 minutes, which gives the detergent time to break down the cell surface membranes and the membranes around the nuclei so that the DNA is released into the mixture.
- Filter the pink mixture through filter paper in a funnel into a boiling tube, so that the insoluble cell walls and lumps of tissue are held back and only the liquid containing the dissolved DNA runs through; collect roughly a 2 cm2\,\text{cm}2cm depth of filtrate.
- Take the ethanol out of the freezer at the last moment, tilt the boiling tube to about 45∘45^\circ45∘, and pour about twice the volume of the filtrate slowly down the inside wall of the tube so that the ethanol settles as a separate clear layer on top of the pink extract instead of mixing with it.
- Stand the tube upright in the rack and leave it undisturbed for 111 to 222 minutes, watching the boundary between the two layers.
- Lift the white threads out on a glass rod by turning the rod slowly at the boundary, so the threads wind onto it.
- Variables: as written this is a preparation rather than an investigation, so nothing is deliberately changed and there is no independent variable. Run as an investigation, the independent variable is the type of fruit or the temperature of the ethanol, and the dependent variable is the amount of DNA obtained, judged from the length or bulk of the threads. Keep the mass of fruit, the volume of extraction buffer, the volume of ethanol and the mashing time the same each time.
- Results: within a minute or two, white stringy threads with tiny bubbles caught in them appear at the boundary where the clear ethanol layer meets the pink fruit extract, and they can be wound onto the glass rod. The extract below stays pink and cloudy. The threads are DNA that has come out of solution because DNA is insoluble in cold ethanol.
- Watch out: stir and squash gently throughout, because froth traps the DNA in the bubbles and hides the threads. Keep the ethanol ice-cold right up to the moment you pour it, since warm ethanol leaves much more of the DNA dissolved and you may see nothing. Pour it slowly down the side of a tilted tube, and do not shake or invert the tube afterwards, because once the two liquids mix there is no boundary for the threads to form at.
- Safety: ethanol is highly flammable and harmful, so keep it well away from any naked flame and wear eye protection. Do not eat any of the fruit used, and wash your hands at the end.
Releasing DNA from cells
Nucleotide
The repeating unit of a DNA strand, made of a sugar and a phosphate group with one of four bases attached to the sugar.
- Mashing or grinding the fruit breaks the cell walls by physical force, so the cell contents are released into the mixture.
- No reagent in the method breaks down cellulose, so the cell walls can only be broken mechanically and this step cannot be left out.
- Washing-up liquid is added because it is a detergent, and detergents break down lipids.
- The cell surface membrane and the membrane around the nucleus are both made largely of lipids, so the detergent breaks these membranes apart and the DNA passes out of the nucleus and out of the cell into the mixture.
- Salt is added because a DNA molecule carries a negative charge along its whole length, since every nucleotide in it contains a phosphate group.
- Two negatively charged DNA molecules repel each other, so on their own they stay spread out and dissolved in the liquid.
- The positively charged sodium ions from the salt are attracted to the negative charges on the DNA and screen them, so the DNA molecules stop repelling one another.
- The DNA molecules can then clump together, which makes them come out of solution far more readily once the ethanol is added.
- Questions often name one step or reagent and ask what it does, so learn the purpose of each stage. The mark is awarded for the function.
- The mark most often dropped is on the detergent: an answer saying it breaks open the cell is too vague to credit, so write that it dissolves the lipid membranes, both the cell surface membrane and the membrane around the nucleus, so that the DNA is released.
- Answer the salt in the same style, saying that it makes the DNA molecules clump together so they come out of solution, rather than simply saying that it helps.
- Where a question gives you a change to the method, such as ethanol left on the bench instead of in the freezer, explain the effect through the same reasoning: warmer ethanol keeps more DNA dissolved, so fewer threads form.
Separating the DNA
- After mashing, the mixture contains the released DNA together with broken cell walls, lumps of tissue that were not broken up and the rest of the cell contents.
- Filtering the mixture holds back the insoluble cell walls and lumps of tissue on the filter paper, so only a liquid containing the dissolved DNA passes through into the tube.
- Ice-cold ethanol is then layered on top of this filtrate.
- DNA is insoluble in cold ethanol, so as the DNA meets the ethanol it comes out of solution and appears as solid white threads.
- Ethanol is less dense than the fruit extract, so pouring it slowly down the side of a tilted tube keeps it as a separate layer, and the threads form at the boundary where the two liquids meet.
- The colder the ethanol, the less DNA stays dissolved, so more DNA comes out of solution and a larger, clearer mass of threads is seen.
- Do not stir or shake hard enough to make froth, because DNA is carried up into the bubbles and the threads are then hidden rather than absent.
- Do not pour ethanol that has been standing at room temperature, because much of the DNA stays in solution and you may see no threads at all.
- Do not tip the ethanol in quickly or invert the tube to mix it, because the two liquids then form one solution and there is no boundary for the threads to gather at.
- Do not skip the filtering step, since lumps of tissue in the tube look like solid material at the boundary and are easily mistaken for DNA.
Identifying the DNA
Genome
The entire DNA of an organism.
- The extracted DNA is seen as white stringy threads at the boundary between the ethanol layer and the fruit extract, often with small bubbles trapped in them.
- The threads are firm enough to be wound onto a glass rod and lifted out of the tube.
- A single DNA molecule is far too thin to be seen, and cannot be resolved even with a light microscope.
- What is visible is very many DNA molecules, released from the nuclei of thousands of cells and clumped together, so the threads are a mass of DNA rather than one molecule.
- The threads contain the whole genome of the fruit cells, because every chromosome is released and precipitated together.
- Nothing about the appearance of the threads reveals which genes the DNA carries, so the extraction shows only that DNA is present and can be handled.
- Why must the fruit be mashed before the detergent is added?
- What does the detergent do to the cell surface membrane and the membrane around the nucleus?
- Why does adding salt make the DNA come out of solution more readily?
- Why must the ethanol be ice-cold and poured slowly down a tilted tube?
- If one DNA molecule is too thin to see, what are the white threads made of?