Applying Ethical Guidelines
- This skill hands you a study you have never seen and asks you to judge its ethics and improve it.
- Because it is unfamiliar, you apply the guidelines to the details in front of you rather than recall a set answer.
- Two moves do the job: spot each issue in the study, then give a fix that matches it.
- Tie every issue to something the study actually does, not to ethics in general.
- Then pair it with a fix and say how the fix protects the participant.
A Worked Example
- A psychologist secretly records conversations at a busy university cafe to study how politely strangers speak to staff.
- The customers are never told they are being recorded, and the audio captures their names and voices.
- The recordings are kept on the researcher's laptop and later played to a seminar group.
- No informed consent: the customers never agreed to take part.
- Invasion of privacy: they are recorded where they reasonably expect not to be studied.
- Broken confidentiality: names and voices could identify them, and the audio is shared.
- No right to withdraw: they cannot leave a study they do not know they are in.
Improving the Study
- For consent, recruit customers who agree to be recorded and brief them first, or if natural behaviour is essential, debrief those recorded afterwards and offer to delete their data.
- For privacy, only record in a clearly public setting where people can reasonably expect to be overheard, not their private conversations.
- For confidentiality, anonymise the audio, strip out names, and never play identifiable clips to others.
- For the missing right to withdraw, tell people afterwards and let them pull their data.
- Do not name an issue the study does not raise; anchor each one to a detail in the scenario.
- Do not give a fix that does not match, such as a debrief to solve a privacy breach on its own.
- Do not call the study ethical once one issue is fixed; check every issue you found.
A Step-by-Step Routine
- Read the study and list each ethical issue, pointing to the detail that raises it.
- Give a matching improvement for each, and say how it protects the participant.
- What two moves does an apply question on ethics need?
- In the cafe study, why is there no informed consent?
- How would you protect confidentiality in a covert recording study?
- Why must each improvement match the issue you named?
- How would you improve the right to withdraw in a covert study?